Movie theaters are all about the shared experience for Bruce E.G. Smith. The 72-year-old Sewickley resident frequented his local multiplex, the Tull Family Theater, at least twice a month before COVID-19 upended the world and made enclosed spaces like movie theaters a dicier proposition.

Mr. Smith enjoyed the “Cheers”-like atmosphere of the Tull, where he would always run into a friend or two. But he hasn’t been there since a March 12 screening of “The Importance of Being Earnest.” He plans to return once he and his wife are vaccinated.

“You can’t beat it. It’s like going to live theater,” said Mr. Smith, a musical theater producer for Front Porch Theatricals. “At least at the Tull, we for sure know someone in the audience.”

Like many local movie theaters, the Tull is currently open and operating as close to normal as possible. But the outlook for in-person theater experiences in 2021 remains out of focus. Will studios continue to hold back or stream blockbusters? Will enough people feel comfortable watching movies surrounded by strangers? Can the theaters survive?

Advertise with us

“The question becomes: How long do you keep trying?” said Paul Looker, owner of Penn Hills Cinemas. “We’re going to go well past the year mark here. How do you run a place with no income for a year?”

The cinephiles

Most movie buffs are missing seeing new films in a theater, but many aren’t sure when or if they will return while cases of COVID-19 remain high and vaccines are not widely accessible.

“I love film and the escape a theater provides,” said Derrick Maultsby Jr., 27, of Downtown, who went to the movies every weekend prior to the pandemic. “As we transition into the post-COVID world, I think I realize a lot of movies are just as good at home. I don’t see myself attending a theater until 2023 at the earliest.”

That sort of mindset has become more prevalent as the release dates for big-budget movies such as the latest “James Bond” are pushed back and Warner Bros. drops another new flick on HBO Max seemingly every week.

Advertise with us

Kim Myers, 40, of North Huntingdon, would go to the movies 10-15 times a year pre-COVID-19, often at the North Versailles Stadium 18 Theater. A big fan of movie theater popcorn, she tried to recreate it at home, “and I nailed it.”

“That said, with streaming services and my popcorn creation, I can’t really find myself wishing I was in a room full of strangers to watch a movie,” she said.

Others are more eager. Joseph Estadt, 29, of East McKeesport, worked at North Versailles Stadium 18 Theater pre-pandemic and would watch films on his days off and after shifts. He hasn’t done that in almost a year. “It’s pretty much the only pre-COVID thing I miss,” he said.

Then there’s Thomas Sheffo, 26, of the South Side, a 10-to-15-movies-a-year guy who said he would happily return to theaters once he feels “an adequate number of people” have been vaccinated.

“It's nowhere near the same feeling of going out and catching the new Marvel release with my mom or brother and getting something to eat before or after at a local restaurant,” he said. “I hope that experience continues to be a vital part of film.”

Advertise with us

The owners

Movie theaters in the region are struggling to stay afloat through what’s already been a long, sad, COVID winter. All three AMC theaters — AMC Waterfront 22, AMC Classic South Hills Village and AMC Classic Mt. Lebanon — are open, though the latter two only on Fridays, Saturdays and Sundays.

“We are working as intently and cleverly as we know how,” AMC Entertainment CEO Adam Aron told CNBC in early January. “We have proven over the past 10 months that we are a resilient, resourceful and creative bunch at AMC.”

Waterworks Cinemas on Freeport Road is also open every day with reduced hours, as are the Cinemark theaters in Robinson, Monroeville Mall and the North Hills.

Smaller theaters are also trying to stay in business. The Hollywood Theater in Dormont is showing a movie or two a day, Tull has a full slate of shows every day, and Penn Hills Cinemas is chugging along, trying to make a few extra bucks through curbside concessions sales and private screenings for groups of movie lovers.

Advertise with us

“It is absolutely the main thing we’re doing right now,” Mr. Looker said of Penn Hills’ private screenings. “I almost wish I could take the regular shows off the schedule. It’s not the same thing as being open, but it’s a light at the end of the tunnel of possibly being able to meet the monthly bills.”

Some theaters, such as The Manor in Squirrel Hill and Row House Cinema in Lawrenceville, kept their doors closed after Gov. Tom Wolf’s last round of shutdowns designed to curb the spread of COVID-19. Both currently offer private screenings, and Row House has a virtual film club that generates some revenue.

“We’re working twice as hard as we did when we were open,” said Row House owner Brian Mendelssohn, but the neighborhood movie house has little revenue to show for it.

“The No. 1 thing a movie theater provides to the public is the one thing we can’t offer right now,” he said of audiences enjoying a film together, “which is why we’re choosing to stay closed right now.”

Back to the future?

Advertise with us

Despite the doom and gloom, there are reasons to hold out hope for movie theaters. The Cinemark 18 in Frazer’s Galleria at Pittsburgh Mills announced in May that it was closing, but from its ashes will rise a new movie theater in the same location. GQT Movies Pittsburgh Mills Cinemas, owned by Michigan-based GQT Movies, is tentatively set to open in March.

GQT Movies was formed last July, a few months after Goodrich Quality Theaters filed for bankruptcy. GQT Movies — whose majority owner is Pittsburgh Mills owner Namdar Realty Group — acquired Goodrich and now owns and operates 22 of Goodrich’s 31 movie theaters in multiple states, with three new ones on the way in Illinois, Alabama and now Pittsburgh.

Matt McSparin, GQT Movies’ chief operating officer, is aware that purchasing an entire chain of movie theaters during a global pandemic may seem, well, insane. But he’s “bullish on the recovery of the industry” as vaccinations become more widespread and a few highly anticipated films seem headed for theaters.

“It’s a tale of feast and famine,” he said. “We’re certainly in the famine right now. The industry’s getting beat to death. Easter should be better times for us, starting there.”

There’s also reason to believe that existing theaters will use the pandemic as an opportunity to innovate. Carolina Thor, Tull Family Theater’s executive director, pointed to the theater’s revamped air-filtration system and safety protocols as evidence of how cineplexes are changing.

Advertise with us

“We are not sitting and waiting,” she said. “We’re rolling up our sleeves and really rethinking everything and looking for ways to serve the community, broaden the scope of our services and to continue our proper stewardship of the investment our patrons have made in us. …

“Like every business once the pandemic is under control, we’re all going to need to adapt and consult with audience comfort and preferences.”

That’s exactly what Matt Santiago, 28, of East Liberty, is hoping to see. He said he went to the movies at least four times a month pre-COVID thanks to his AMC Stubs A-List membership. He’s tried watching movies at home and even did a private screening of “Tenet” with friends at Waterworks Cinemas, but he was “still uncomfortable with it.”

“In a theater, it’s a community experience and feels like a community event we’re all experiencing together as a country,” he said. “On streaming … it’s sort of a fleeting experience. It just really takes away from the impact of those movies and makes them feel less important.”

Mr. Santiago is confident that movie theaters will remain an important part of American pop culture — in an updated form.

Advertise with us

“I don’t see the movie theater experience disappearing,” he said. “It just needs to transform in some way with the crowd.”

Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxel222.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.