The “whodunnit” in Rian Johnson’s delightfully twisted “Knives Out” is almost secondary to the “howdunnit.”
Johnson managed to get this extremely star-studded mystery quickly made during a break in Daniel Craig’s “007” schedule, and we are the better for it. From the opening shot of a looming, red brick manor set amid wind-blown leaves to the intimate betrayals of friends and family later, the inner workings at play will delight any Agatha Christie fan.
But it’s not just an enigmatic drama. “Knives Out” is funny and droll, and if there is any downside to having a cast this large and talented, it’s that there simply isn’t time to give everyone their due.
'KNIVES OUT'

- Starring: Daniel Craig, Ana de Amas, Chris Evans, Jamie Lee Curtis.
- Rating: PG-13 for adult language, some violence.
The plot is simple: Celebrated mystery writer Harlan Thrombey (Christopher Plummer) is discovered dead in his overstuffed upstairs study. A lavish birthday party had been held that evening. Who killed him and why?
Any number of the odious family members who stood to inherit his vast fortune had reason to cut Harlan’s throat. There’s Harlan’s daughter Linda (Jamie Lee Curtis), her husband Richard (Don Johnson), their jerk of a son, Ransom (Chris Evans). Then there’s the novelist’s daughter-in-law, New Wave-y Joni (Toni Collette) and son Walt (Michael Shannon), the latter in charge of Harlan’s publishing empire but angry because daddy wouldn’t let go of the reins. The list of suspects goes on.
Two local law enforcement officers (Lakeith Stanfield and Noah Segan) are the backup singers to Craig’s lead investigator, the wonderfully named Benoit Blanc. Blanc lounges on the mansion’s ornate furniture. (There is an Iron Throne-like chair made of weapons that every mystery writer should have). He delivers his enigmatic opinions in a slow, Southern drawl.
“I read a tweet about a New Yorker article about you!” gushes Joni. “You’re famous.”
“You will find me a quite passive, respective observer of the truth,” he tells the assembled family. Indeed, he is.
Director Johnson’s previous works include genre-creative takes such as “Brick” and “Looper.” (He also directed “Star Wars: The Last Jedi.”).
“Knives Out” is clever and thrilling, and it’s also socially aware. Our protagonist, the luminous and vulnerable Marta (Ana de Amas), is referred to disparagingly as “an anchor baby.” Members of the Thrombey clan talk about adoring young Marta — who was Harlan’s friend and nurse companion — as one of the family. And yet, they can’t quite remember; which Spanish-speaking country is her family from?
A younger member of the Thrombey clan is a budding neo-Nazi. So there’s that, too.
A series of flashbacks provide texture but perhaps no real clues. It appears almost everyone had a solid motive for killing Harlan. Possibly the only one above the fray is Marta, who literally cannot lie without getting sick to her stomach.
Johnson has fun with his screenplay, giving this talented group of actors their scenes of high drama and bad behavior. It’s as if the Roy family on “Succession” finally decided to murder patriarch Logan.
A downside of Agatha Christie’s stiff-upper-lip novels was the author waiting until the end of the book to spring some complicated explanation for the crime. There’s little fun if there’s no real chance of solving the mystery. It’s a tricky thing to pull off at the movies as well (see: 2017’s “Murder on the Orient Express,” which had plot holes big enough to drive a locomotive through).
Johnson has said in interviews that he wants the audience to have a sporting chance. And while there are devious twists and turns in “Knives Out,” the director skillfully guides us into believing we know where this train is headed.
“Look around, the guy practically lived in a ‘Clue’ board,” says Stanfield’s Lt. Elliott. Perhaps there’s no Col. Mustard in the kitchen with the wrench, but “Knives Out” knows exactly where to place its players.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.