Most people who will see “Captain Marvel” and have parts of it explained to them by comic book aficionados will be surprised to learn that Carol Danvers, aka Captain Marvel, is one of the most powerful heroes in the Marvel universe.

In terms of sheer power, she’s stronger than Iron Man and is like Thor in her ability to manipulate cosmic forces and travel through space without the aid of technology. Compared to characters in the rival DC universe, she’s closer to being Superman on the spectrum of superpowers than Wonder Woman.

Still, in terms of popularity with the comic book reading/buying base, Carol Danvers/Captain Marvel has been a C-level character for much of the last 40 years. The character’s gender is likely a factor for chauvinistic male comic readers as well as a series of lackluster creative teams who neglected Captain Marvel’s potential.

A few years ago, the character was revamped by writer Kelly Sue DeConnick who imbued her with much needed “badassery” and upgraded her powers considerably. Most importantly, Ms. DeConnick gave Carol Danvers compelling and highly personal story arcs for the first time in the character’s history.

Advertise with us

'Captain Marvel'

Ratings explained

  • Starring: Brie Larson, Samuel L. Jackson, Ben Mendelsohn, Jude Law, Annette Bening, Lashana Lynch.
  • Rating: PG-13 sequences of sci-fi violence and action, and brief suggestive language.

Though the comic book has been relatively successful, including selling out its print run at times under Ms. DeConnick, Captain Marvel has yet to make an impact on popular culture beyond the armies of appreciative fan girls, who see her as a character who reflects their own pent-up aspirations.

Carol Danvers is more role model than culture spanning icon at this point, because most people who will see “Captain Marvel” because it is the latest installment of Marvel’s decade-spanning superhero movie franchise won’t have any idea who she is.

That’s why the much anticipated movie starring Brie Larson as the title character is such a disappointment, though still worth seeing. For those counting down the weeks until “Avengers: Endgame” hits screens later this spring, this movie contains one post-credit sequence that will have to satisfy you until the main dish.

Advertise with us

Because we got only a hint of Carol Danvers’ existence at the end of “Avengers: Infinity War” as Nick Fury (Samuel L. Jackson) was summoning her, it was up to “Captain Marvel” to introduce and establish the character’s origin as well as the parameters of her powers.

The movie does so in the most confounding way possible using the title character’s amnesia, a nostalgia-drenched narrative that unfolds in 1995 and an “alien invasion” back story with an unexpected twist.

When we meet Carol Danvers, she is known as Vers. She is an elite warrior-in-training on the home-world of the Kree Empire. The Kree were the villains of the first “Guardians of the Galaxy” movie. They are humanoids who run the racial gamut from black to blue to white, so an Earthling with amnesia doesn’t stick out in that world.

Because Vers doesn’t know who she is, she leans on her sensei Yon-Rogg (Jude Law) for guidance. He encourages her to channel her strange powers by learning to control her impulses. He dispenses a lot of self-help bromides.

Vers also communes with the Kree Empire’s Supreme Intelligence (Annette Bening). The Supreme Intelligence takes the form of someone Vers respects from her subconscious. The problem is that Vers can’t remember who that person is.

Advertise with us

We learn that the Kree are at war with the shape-shifting race the Skrulls. Vers is part of a team that includes Yon-Rogg and Korath (Djimon Hounsou) that has located a band of Skrulls on a distant planet.

When their reconnaissance mission goes south, Vers is captured by the Skrulls. The leader of the vaguely reptilian Skrulls is Talos (Ben Mendelsohn), and he provides the movie with its most consistently enjoyable performances. His very noticeable Australian accent is as much a character as he is.

Vers escapes from the Skrulls’ ship and crash-lands at a Blockbuster Video store in Los Angeles on Earth in 1995. The Skrulls hunt her (and she, them) on a planet that looks and feels vaguely familiar to her.

Shortly after arriving on Earth, Vers meets S.H.I.E.L.D agent Nick Fury (with two decades wiped away by digital special effects) and guilelessly tells him that she’s a Kree warrior hunting Skrulls on his planet.

Fury’s initial incredulity turns into belief once he sees Vers in action. They form a partnership to hunt the Skrulls together. Meanwhile, Vers, who assumes she’s as much a Kree as her fellow warriors, realizes she has a connection to Earth she simply doesn’t remember. She commits herself to finding the answers.

Advertise with us

The movie then becomes Vers’ search for her past as she attempts to knit together her fractured memories of girlhood, teen life and young adulthood training for the U.S. Air Force on this planet. When she meets former fighter pilot Maria Rambeau (Lashana Lynch) and her daughter, the pieces begin falling together.

The movie then becomes a journey of self-discovery for Vers, who learns she’s “Carol Danvers.” The problem is that there isn’t sufficient tension to hold the movie together as the revelations unfold.

There is an unexpected plot shift regarding the supporting characters, but it comes too late in a film mired in dull action sequences and painfully flat dialogue at times. Even the attempt at ’80s-style buddy movie rapport between Fury and Vers feels forced because Carol Danvers is a fish out of water in her own movie. How can she be funny or interesting if she doesn’t know who she is?

More than anything, “Captain Marvel” feels like Marvel/Disney saw an opportunity to push a dynamic female superhero to the front ranks of the male-centric MCU after “Wonder Woman” proved a female superhero film could be both a commercial and critical success.

Instead of something pathbreaking, “Captain Marvel” feels like it is the first draft of something that has the potential to be really special. Ms. Larson is terrific despite being stuck with subpar material. Still, no one invested more into his or her role than Mr. Mendelsohn as Talos. Maybe the key to getting the best material in a Marvel movie is to take on the role as the villain.

Advertise with us

Working from a screenplay they wrote with Geneva Robertson-Dworet, co-directors Anna Boden and Ryan Fleck have put together a crowd-pleasing film that will make a ton of money. There are plenty of female-affirming moments and a soundtrack specific to that era that is as exciting as any Marvel/Disney has done. It’s not a bad film, but “Captain Marvel” needed to be something special and transcendent. It is far from that. It loses points because we don’t really find out who Carol Danvers is until the end. The stakes never feel raised.

Still, this critic saw it at a screening filled with comic book geeks who were overwhelmingly white and male who seemed to love it. One older fan said he’d “bought the whole thing.” Maybe “Captain Marvel” won’t be such a hard sale with this demographic after all.

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.