What you remember of Gary Hart, if indeed you remember much, might well be inaccurate.
The boat christened “Monkey Business”? That photo in the National Enquirer, with a young blonde, Donna Rice, sitting on the lap of a smiling Mr. Hart? His challenge to reporters to “follow me around”?
Jason Reitman, who co-wrote and directed “The Front Runner,” said this was one of the fascinations that inspired him. Having listened to the “Radiolab” program in 2016 about Mr. Hart, “I Don’t Have To Answer That,” he began asking friends what they recalled from this strange history lesson.
“Gary Hart served as sort of this strange pH test where you had this smart, charismatic candidate with big ideas and he was kind of prescient beyond imagination. ...
“I found people reacted to the story either empathizing with Hart or empathizing with Donna or empathizing with the journalists, or, they would think this was the beginning of the #MeToo movement — every response was different.
“And by that nature, I found most people don’t know the actual story.”
The facts are these: Colorado Sen. Hart was leading the polls in the spring of 1987. Young, smart and progressive, he appeared to be well on his way toward securing the Democratic party’s endorsement. Following a Miami Herald stakeout of a Capitol Hill townhouse, the newspaper very publicly accused him of having an extramarital affair. Mr. Hart, who was famously guarded about his private life, appeared incredulous anyone would care.
This was nobody’s business.
Indeed, the relationship between politicians and the media — might as well throw in top athletes and rock stars while you’re at it — had been, more or less up to that point, one of see and don’t tell.
For more than 30 years, there has been great speculation as to what actually happened. A recent article in The Atlantic suggests Mr. Hart was set up by Republican strategist/hitman Lee Atwater.
Matt Bai’s 2014 book “All The Truth Is Out” suggests there was no affair (Mr. Bai was a source for that Radiolab program). Mr. Hart, portrayed in the film by a perfectly coiffed Hugh Jackman, eventually dropped out of the race despite his popularity in the polls.
Mr. Reitman wrote the screenplay with Mr. Bai, based on the author’s account, which was in cooperation with Mr. Hart. Regardless of what might or might not have happened, Mr. Reitman said, “In less than a week, this became a tabloid story instead of an actual, national conversation.
“And in that moment, we threw a candidate away, and really said something about what we were looking for in this country. Which kinds of puts us in the notion of a celebrity candidate who knows how to deal with the paparazzi, and that kind of puts us on the road to shamelessness.”
Mr. Reitman, a multiple Oscar nominee for “Up In The Air” (2009) and “Juno” (2007), said Mr. Hart “didn’t see the point in posing for People magazine, let along answering questions about his marriage or sex life.
“He really thought there was sort of this strong line between these ideas. Of course, we now live in a world where there is no line. I think he walked away because he was not going to participate in a presidential contest in which conversations about his sex life would take precedent over the conversation about the big ideas.”
As for that photo from the National Enquirer, it isn’t in the movie, not even in the epilogue.
“I think it actually points to the misunderstanding of this story,” said Mr. Reitman, noting the Monkey Business picture was published well after Mr. Hart had resigned.
“I think the fact that we think of that photo more than almost anything else in this story points to our ‘tabloidian’ curiosity. ... The political story is someone who enters the race and for three weeks is 10 points ahead of George [H.W.] Bush and 25 points ahead of every Democrat.
“And three weeks later, he’s out. For me, that was the story. These three weeks. It’s not even a biopic about Gary Hart all so much as it’s a movie about the rest of us.”
Maria Sciullo: msciullo@post-gazette.com or @MariaSciulloPG.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.