Joel J. Tyler, who as a Manhattan judge ruled, in a particularly explicit and colorful opinion, that the pornographic film "Deep Throat" was obscene and that the New York City theaters showing it were breaking the law, inadvertently helping it become perhaps the most popular X-rated movie of all time, died in New York on Nov. 9. He was 90.

The cause was a heart attack, his daughter Alexandra said. She said the family did not report his death until now because her father did not want the acknowledgment. But in the weeks after his death, she said, she and her sister, Lisa, "came to feel overwhelmingly that he deserved it."

Judge Tyler, a former city commissioner of licenses, had been on the Criminal Court bench for four years when "Deep Throat" opened at the New Mature World Theater on June 12, 1972. The film, about a woman whose quest for sexual satisfaction is frustrated until she discovers that her clitoris is in her throat, almost immediately became a touchstone in the culture wars of the day.

On one side was outrage over the film's flagrant and unashamed depiction of sex acts; on the other was cheering for its daring to confront social taboos and to present a woman's sexual needs as being as robust as a man's.

Advertise with us

A notorious artifact, "Deep Throat" became a target in the early efforts of New York City to rid Times Square of its seamier elements. In August that year, complaints were lodged by the Police Department and charges were filed against Mature Enterprises, the company that owned the theater, for promotion of obscene material. The trial began in December 1972.

A psychiatrist testified that the sexual acts depicted in the film were "well within the bounds of normal behavior." A film critic testified that "Deep Throat" had redeeming social value -- a key element in the definition of obscenity -- because it showed sympathy for female desires, because the script contained humor and because, unlike other porn films, it was photographed "with clarity and lack of grain."

On the other hand, a New York University professor, responding to a claim that the film was at least in part a spoof of sexual behavior, said, "I do not see how you can spoof fellatio by showing continuous performance of fellatio."

On March 1, 1973, Judge Tyler came down stridently against the film, though not without literary flourish. In an opinion that came with a long appendix, he called "Deep Throat" "this feast of carrion and squalor," "a nadir of decadence" and "a Sodom and Gomorrah gone wild before the fire."

"Oh, yes! There is a gossamer of a story line -- the heroine's all-engrossing search for sexual gratification, and when all sexual endeavors fail to gratify, her unique problem is successfully diagnosed to exist in her throat," he wrote, adding, "The alleged story lines are the facade, the sheer negligee through which clearly shines the producer's and the defendant's true and only purpose, that is, the presentation of unmistakably hard-core pornography."

Advertise with us

Judge Tyler fined Mature Enterprises $100,000, which was later reduced on appeal.

Born Josel Gonigman on July 28, 1921, in Balti, a Romanian city now a part of Moldova, Judge Tyler came to the United States with his family as an infant.

He attended Indiana University and finished his undergraduate education at New York University before graduating from law school at Fordham. His first job was in the law department of the Allied Chemical and Dye Corp. He opened his own practice in 1951.

Mayor John Lindsay named him licensing commissioner in 1966, a post he held until 1968. Afterward, he served on the Criminal Court of New York and was an acting state Supreme Court justice and then a federal magistrate until he retired in 1991.

Judge Tyler's ruling added to the must-see cachet of "Deep Throat." The film eventually reopened in New York (with a few scenes cut) and across the country, closely followed by officials scrambling to shut it down.

Advertise with us

The film, which was made for $25,000 by the director Gerald Damiano, a former hairdresser, earned an estimated $600 million.

Judge Tyler, whose reputation as a prude frustrated him, recognized that his ruling was a function of its era.

"If I were to write that appendix today," he told The New York Law Journal in 1991, "I would be deemed a fool, given the substantial change in our outlook."