"Troy" makes an age-old observation that never goes out of style, judging from current events -- look at some of the people who cause soldiers to go to war, and at some of the reasons why.

'Troy'

Rating: R for graphic violence and some sexuality/nudity.

Starring: Brad Pitt, Eric Bana, Orlando Bloom, Peter O'Toole.

Advertise with us

Director: Wolfgang Petersen.

More than three millennia old, the story of the Trojan War tells how Paris (Orlando Bloom), a prince of Troy, starts a war by abducting (or seducing) a Greek king's beautiful wife, Helen (German actress Diane Kruger). Never mind that he has just helped conclude a peace treaty between the two nations or, as his brother Hector (Eric Bana) tells this impetuous, whiny pup, "You don't know anything about love or war."

Paris plays right into the hands of King Agamemnon (Brian Cox), who conquered his Greek neighbors to take control of the peninsula and now seeks fresh blood. His brother, Menelaus (Brendan Gleeson), wants his wife back mainly so he can strangle her with his bare hands.

Only Hector, far smarter and more competent than his brother, fights for what seems like the right reason -- to defend his country against invaders, even if his side was responsible for provoking the war.

Hector learned well at the foot of his father, King Priam (Peter O'Toole) -- enough not to pay attention to Priam's priests and advisers, who assure him that God (or, in this case, the gods) are on Troy's side. Too bad his father believes them.

Advertise with us

The Greeks believe the gods are on their side, except for their greatest warrior, a man with no allegiance to Greece, to Agamemnon (whom he detests) or to anyone but himself and his own troops. "The gods are jealous of me," says Achilles (Brad Pitt), an arrogant, often disruptive force interested only in his own legacy. He knows the Greeks can't win without him and often he doesn't care, even when his own vainglory is at stake.

No wonder the Trojan War lasted 10 years, according to Homer's epic account, "The Iliad." Most of the people for whom the soldiers in "Troy" die aren't worth the dirt beneath the feet of these valiant fighters.

The chief exceptions are Hector and Priam, whom even Achilles comes to acknowledge as a better man than anyone on his own side. A clandestine meeting between the two characters is the highlight of the movie, thanks to the welter of honest emotions in O'Toole's face -- his presence also seems to boost Pitt, who pulls off the role of Achilles better than you might think.

Arrogant and vainglorious? Where's the stretch? It's in the way he turns Achilles into a cynical fatalist who somehow still manages to fit the time in which he lives.

"Troy" doesn't follow the exact letter of "The Iliad," but only purists should mind. Homer was a poet, not a historian, and the Trojan War may be more myth than reality.

Advertise with us

Director Wolfgang Petersen and screenwriter David Benioff ("The 25th Hour") weren't about to spend 10 years in Troy (the movie is long enough at 163 minutes). Certain characters appear to die during the war who survived it in the Iliad. The Greek gods are mentioned often but never intervene as they do in the poem.

Petersen, whose films include "The Perfect Storm," "Air Force One" and the magnificent submarine movie "Das Boot," knows how to stage an action scene, and the many battles in the film tend to carry the movie. The best of these scenes pit opponents from opposite sides in one-on-one grudge matches, which allows the characters to display passions that would be lost in a more general din.

It doesn't help that Benioff fails to develop most of his characters -- except for Achilles, Paris and Priam, most of them end the film (or their roles in it) pretty much where they started. He also makes them utter enough stale and corny dialogue that we may think these lines originated in the Trojan War.

When thousands of soldiers in computer-generated armies face off on the plain in front of Troy's impregnable walls, it calls to mind (deliberately, I'm sure) the calm just before the storm at Minas Tirith in "Lord of the Rings."

That trilogy contained one strong female role after another. Most of the female characters in this movie either spend their time dithering in fear or giving in to Achilles. (Pitt does have two scenes in which he wears nothing but manages to hide all his key parts nonetheless.)

Advertise with us

Paris is no prize, a fresh-faced whelp who does almost everything wrong (the one time he's right, of course, no one listens to him).

And so "Troy" swings its swords, hefts its axes, hurls its spears, shoots its arrows, unleashes its fires while James Horner's music fills the air with wails. It's an impressive spectacle that only sporadically achieves a more human dimension.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.