The Kelly Critics is a joint program of the Post-Gazette and Pittsburgh CLO's Gene Kelly Awards for Excellence in High School Musicals, in which students at Kelly schools review musicals at other Kelly schools. Reviews are edited by senior theater critic Christopher Rawson. For more high school musicals coverage, go to www.post-gazette.com/ae/theater-dance and scroll down. Click here for the full schedule of spring high school musicals in Western Pennsylvania.

The snow crunching and crackling under my feet as I wandered into Pine-Richland High School soon transformed into warm, dusty Egyptian sands as I began my journey into a colorful and thrilling biblical experience. As we, the audience, powered down our iphones and temporarily abandoned our busy, rushed weeks, the energy in the auditorium shifted to what can only be related to the atmosphere on a ship full of vacationers ready to embark on a tour of a fantastic foreign land.

Our “ship” leaves the dock the moment “Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat” begins and the spotlight centers on the first of the three narrators. The audience is captivated, and our fascination only grows as three beautifully dressed young narrators begin to lead us through the show in song. As the plot progresses, we are introduced to Joseph and his family, along with a number of other funky and fun characters such as Pharaoh and the Egyptians. The show leads the audience through the classic tale of Joseph and his coat of many colors, and explores the ideas of family, freedom, and most importantly, forgiveness.

Our ship took a variety of detours as we journeyed through the plot, stopping so the audience could observe a number of moments and details that stood out as spectacular. From the use of towels to make sheep, to the addition of blue suede shoes on Elvis Pharaoh, there was no feature left neglected in the realm of costumes and props. The best example of the supreme work done behind the scenes was the costume and special features that defined the brothers who were played by women. Yet, when it came to the sets, certain pieces, such as the sphynx display, lacked detail and could have benefitted from more attention.

Advertise with us

During the show, the transitions of emotion came off as natural and effortless. In the song, “One More Angel in Heaven,” the brothers did a lovely job of making the audience chuckle as they snapped back and forth between pity and pride. Helen Krushinski wowed the crowd in her role as a narrator as she sang out “Poor, Poor Joseph.” Together, Helen, Paige Nelson, and Emily Stephen all worked together well as the narrators and instilled excitement in the audience as we anxiously waited to hear what beautiful song they would share with us next.

As our ship sails on, we gather on the deck to observe that one of the strongest highlights came in one of the most unexpected moments. As Joseph, played by Jake Pedersen, sang his solo, imprisoned in Egypt, the audience was still and silent. This smooth and almost haunting scene offered a classy and beautiful interpretation of the hopelessness Joseph was experiencing, and gifted the audience with a delicate reprieve from the previous fun and games. Yet, only moments later the energy and excitement was back and better than ever with the entertaining frenzy of “Go, Go, Go Joseph.”

While floating along the deep seas of excitement and fun, our ship hit what had the potential to be some rough waters. Naturally, in a world full of vibrant religious debates and political disagreement over the separation of church and state, one is prone to come into any performance of a show based on a biblical story with a number of expectations and perhaps even some strong premonitions. In my case, as a Christian who has been in Catholic school all of my life, I found myself struggling to keep an open mind to the idea of high school students glamorizing (or maybe exploiting) an age-old religious story for the sake of entertainment.

Yet, only moments into the show, I felt these concerns and judgments slip away in a cloud of pure joy and amusement. Both the original writers and the students who performed and managed the production did a beautiful job of walking the tightrope between being fun and respecting the religious elements. For viewers who have not been exposed to this show’s biblical roots, the show was surely an amazing experience; however I would argue that it may have had an even more intense impact on those of us who knew the mother-story from a young age. The adaptation, interpretation, and addition of humor to this classic plot captured the Christian viewers and allowed us to get excited about a story that otherwise we may have come to take for granted.

While the show was executed wonderfully in general, it was not without a few technical flaws. The most distracting shortcoming involved sound. At times, the orchestra, principles, and ensemble all seemed to be competing to be heard over one another. It was challenging to concentrate on the plot being expressed through the songs when the score was so loud. In addition to this, the mics cut out a few times.

As our ship returned to dock and the night came to a close, I heard the clock strike 9:30 and felt the warm African sands turn back to snow under my boots. The show was simply spectacular, and I did not want it to end. From the costumes to the score to the performers themselves, it was truly a Technicolor dream.