Born and raised in one of the poorest neighborhoods in the Bronx, Shaun Ossei-Owusu, a professor at the University of Pennsylvania Law School, describes himself as a ”Black Black” or “a sneaker-wearing, hip hop referencing, first generation everything,” with an afro “that occasionally transforms into cornrows,” who maintains deep connections with family and friends living in economic uncertainty.
In “Law On Trial,” Ossei-Owusu documents the myriad ways in which legal education and practice, informed by a belief that zealous advocacy in an adversarial system produces just outcomes, teaches lawyers to disconnect their profession “from its social implications.”
The law’s machinery and its “cool, clinical language,” he asserts, “erodes already compromised democratic ideals” and provides “an orderly way to manage inequality rather than eliminate it.”
Ossei-Owusu’s informative, passionate, take-no-prisoners critique of law schools, elite firms, federal, state and local government attorneys, and even well-intentioned public interest advocates, should command the attention of every American, liberal or conservative, who is concerned that the current system falls far short of the ideals of justice, equality and fairness.
The indictment of “Law on Trial” is comprehensive and concrete.
By implying that emotional detachment is a professional imperative, Ossei-Owusu asserts, law courses tend to treat morality (what’s right and wrong) and bias as “background noise,” rather than forces influencing how legal systems “see, sort and decide.”
After citing a study in which 98% of respondents signed documents with opaque language in which they gave up their first-born child as payment for access to a fake social media network, he suggests that law schools imply that surrendering a right to sue is the price of getting basic services from credit card companies, utilities and internet plans.
Law school instructors tend to transform freedom of contract from what is often economic coercion into voluntary agreements among equals. They push domestic violence into family law.
“Drenched in ideas of neutrality,” torts courses address private parties causing harm far more often than holding public officials liable for their actions. Homelessness and gentrification receive little attention in property law courses.
Criminal law courses focus on interpersonal violence at the expense of money-laundering; insider trading; bid rigging for government contracts; mail, bank, accounting, mortgage and securities fraud; and other white-collar offenses.
Civil procedure students don’t hear much about how rules, like “forum shopping” (deciding which courts will hear lawsuits) and “equipage” (the resources needed to litigate effectively), operate as weapons in the hands of wealthy parties. Constitution scholars on the left and right package “fights about humanity” – voting rights, health care, police violence – “as debates about interpretive techniques.”
When students graduate and practice law, Ossei-Owusu indicates, Lady Justice’s blindfold all too often “is a fashionable accessory she lifts for the right person.”
Inequality remains alive and well in plea bargaining agreements imposed by prosecutors on poor defendants; underfunded public defense and civil legal aid attorneys; settlements of cases involving police misconduct; restrictions on class action suits: assaults on climate change regulations; multi-billion-dollar mergers and acquisition deals that eliminate competition, result in emergency room closures, and “drive up prices for working families.”
Ossei-Owusu recognizes that readers of his “harsh appraisal” may declare that “complaining is easy” and ask for solutions. In a brief conclusion, he makes a few recommendations for lawyers and non-lawyers he deems “specific and as practical as possible.”
They are, alas, mostly vague and hortatory, such as support for investigative journalism and watchdog organizations; vigilance by voters in elections for government prosecutors, a mixture of “introspection and disruption” by district attorneys, and “political tithing by” Big Law attorneys.
And so, “Law on Trial” leaves us far more knowledgeable about important and impactful shortcomings in a profession, as Ossie-Owusu knows as well or better than anyone, “relies on machinery vaster than any of our imaginations” that’s been decades in the making, rendering it extraordinarily resistant to change.
Glenn C. Altschuler is The Thomas and Dorothy Litwin Emeritus Professor of American Studies at Cornell University.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.