I recently confessed to a Jane Austen scholar and friend a closely held secret: I’d never read “Pride and Prejudice.”

The longer I’d waited, the more my English degree had mocked me from its 20-year basement-bin home. Finally, I decided to plug the gap. If you’re like me, fear not. Austen’s comedy of manners is, above all, a comedy. A romantic one. Just don’t expect a rom-com.

The template is there, and one worth recognizing, especially as we celebrate 150 years since the author’s birth. Intelligent, independent Elizabeth Bennet meets intelligent, independent Mr. Darcy and hates him. They are, naturally, marked for each other.

Luckily, Elizabeth has four sisters to absorb less worthy suitors. Unluckily, it’s early-1800s England, and the family has no son to inherit the family estate. Whenever papa Bennet croaks, his odious cousin-heir could evict any unmarried sister.

Advertise with us

The novel’s first line, “It is a truth universally acknowledged, that a single man in possession of a good fortune must be in want of a wife,” couldn’t more neatly invert the problem. The rich dudes are just fine. All the single ladies better put a ring on it.

I wanted to be mad at this literary totem. Why should we celebrate such systemic gender oppression? Why should I care about these rich people problems? So what if the sisters fall down their stupid social ladder into some other relative’s mansion or even – gasp! – employment?

My English degree stirred in its box, and I read on. I occasionally caught myself tuning out of some of the longer-winded conversations. But I had to admire the prose: always precise and sometimes hilarious. When some acquaintances of Elizabeth fail to pay enough attention to her older sister, “their indifference towards Jane when not immediately before them restored Elizabeth to the enjoyment of all her former dislike.”

Charmed at last, I set aside my reflex to bully the book with 21st century morality. If I want my own views reflected back at me, well, that’s what social media is for.

“Pride and Prejudice” is a work of its time. Why should I expect it to be any more revolutionary than “Sleepless in Seattle”? Austen does concentrate social-status obsession in the story’s least likable characters. But ultimately she follows the rom-com rule: no real harm but to the heart.

Advertise with us

Once I got over myself, I could appreciate that the book exemplifies what novels do best: mental interiority. Austen crafts the tiny movements of Elizabeth’s thoughts and feelings, loyalties and longings, and yes, pride and prejudice. When at last she – spoiler alert – confesses her love to Darcy, it lands with the certainty of a grandfather clock striking noon.

Certainty and bloodlessness – by “Bridgerton” standards. True to Austen’s time, passion is the near-ruinous fault of Elizabeth’s eloping sister, Lydia. Elizabeth and Darcy, on the other hand, spend their climactic encounter explaining themselves.

The story ends not with their wedding, a kiss, or even just Elizabeth and Darcy. Like an accountant closing out the company books, the final chapters tick off each side character’s judgment of the couple’s engagement. When a marriage could rearrange the land-wealth social order, it pays to check for leaks.

This actuarial conclusion made me question why the modern rom-com’s happy ending is so fixated on the couple’s joy. What reassurance do we get from fading out on the airport-terminal clench? I’d never have thought to ask that if I hadn’t found a way around impostor syndrome.

However you encounter Austen, be it audiobook or a physical copy, perhaps you, like me, will see why my Austen-loving friend kept returning to her. At once familiar and foreign, “Pride and Prejudice” ticks like an antique music box. If you’re brave enough to open it.

Paul Ruggiero is a writer and editor who lives in Pittsburgh.