In slang, a “clutch friend” is a person you can count on no matter what; a clutch of friends is a small group who will always be there for you. Emily Nemens’s new novel “Clutch” revolves around such a friend group, five women who first met in college and are now scattered across the U.S., entering their 40s, leading full and messy lives, and leaning on their friendships with each other.
“This, this is perfection,” they think when together early in the novel despite all of the conflicts in their lives — a sentiment partly aided by hallucinogens.
Taking place over the course of just a few months as former actress and current Texas state senator Gregg decides whether to run for a seat as a U.S. congresswoman, “Clutch” is a character-driven novel bookended by gatherings of this tight group of heterosexual white women whose friendship is in fact imperfect, sometimes competitive, sometimes lopsided, always complicated, but still a refuge and source of support.
Gregg, married to the equally ambitious Zeke, finds herself reluctantly pregnant as she grapples with “quite a few metaphors for what it felt like to be a progressive public official in Texas with two kiddos under 3: treading water in the middle of the ocean, draining a lake with an eyedropper, moving a mountain with a teaspoon.”
Reba, seen by her friends as bossy and a control freak who is still “usually right,” has left behind a management consultant job to be a homemaker and is facing infertility. Bella’s a mother of two sons and Manhattan corporate litigator hoping to become a partner in her firm, yet increasingly questioning the value of the seemingly trivial case that will get her there.
Hillary, also a mother and married to a man whose addictions often get the better of him, works as a physician in Chicago. And finally, as the only one who has hung on to artistic ambitions despite their costs and “eschewed the pull of creature comforts and the empty affirmations of a big paycheck,” Carson is a single, childless writer who still lives with roommates in Brooklyn.
While the lack of plot can make the novel occasionally feel a bit static, the richness of character, language and metaphor ultimately makes up for that. Likewise, the omniscient narrator can be both a strength and weakness.
Skillfully handled for the most part, it brings an intimacy and authority to the narrative and constantly reminds us that this group exists as a collective as well as distinctively portrayed individuals, even when it can sometimes, particularly in its reflections on time and responsibility, edge toward didacticism. Still, this narrative voice refreshingly refuses any neat wrap-ups or easy victimization despite betrayal.
When in her novel-in-progress Carson works to “seamlessly move between a character’s interiority and his external interactions,” this line summarizes the narrative strategy of “Clutch” so well that one wonders if the novel we’re reading is actually the novel that Carson is writing.
It’s Bella who summarizes their friendship and personal fates when she leaves a message toward the end of the book apologizing for having underestimated her friends, commenting “what wonderful and kind friends they had been for so long. . . .they’d brought out such richness, such joy and strong hallucinogens, so much fashion inspiration and sane medical advice into her life.”
She goes on to say, “She was sorry to have not been better able to recognize what she did have, which was a lot of privilege and opportunity and a life that, battered as it was, could still be a good one. Just not as she’d imagined.”
Nancy McCabe is an emeritus professor of creative and professional writing at the University of Pittsburgh at Bradford and the author of nine books, most recently the middle-grade novel “Fires Burning Underground” and the satirical novel “The Pamela Papers: A Mostly Epistolary Story of Academic Pandemic Pandemonium.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.