Tahirah J. Walker’s “Rhetoric, Intersectionality, and Black Women in Pittsburgh: Living Enough for the City” will be a hard book for the average reader, written in a language both technical and sometimes imprecise.
Walker argues in this book that rhetoric is an area where intersectionality occurs. Or, as Walker puts it, “Interlocking systems of oppression, such as race, gender, class, and sexuality, manifest in discourse throughout the public and private spheres.”
In this argument, “Black women in Pittsburgh” are an example of a population that experiences oppression in the ways they are talked about, for being not just Black and not just women, but Black women specifically, and how they react to those experiences, reinforcing the notion that Pittsburgh is not “livable” for everyone.
Although memoiristic sections are interwoven throughout, most of the book is written in a level of academese that requires either experience or extreme patience to disentangle.
In defining “intersectionality,” Walker also says that intersectionality can be defined as responses to intersectionality: “By rhetorical intersectionality, I mean both attempts at oppression and the rejection of it or liberation from it, regardless of whether either is successful in a tangible sense.”
This is fine, although it means that the definition has already slipped from a systemic effect — intersectionality as a thing that happens, rhetorical intersectionality as a way of saying “that thing happens in speech, too” — to an intentional attempt or the success or failure of that attempt.
The first part of the book is dedicated to developing that definition; the next is dedicated to offering and analyzing examples, historical and contemporary, usually led by Walker’s own lived experience, of Black women in Pittsburgh through silence and silencing, speaking out and truth-telling (“parrhesia,” or speaking truth to power), and listening.
A funny thing happens over the course of those chapters, though. Walker clarifies her definition. By chapter 6, “Reclamation, Leadership, and Livability,” anything that is oppression is intersectionality, and anything that is resistance is rhetorical intersectionality. This shift is certainly more easily understood than the imprecision that envelops the book’s beginning.
That these values live so uneasily together in the text — that complication, however contradictory and frustrating, is eventually sacrificed in the interest of relevance — is, perhaps, the most significant disappointment of this book: It tries to do two things, one academic, one activist; and in so doing, it winds up making both less effective.
A text being hard to read is not a bad thing in and of itself. At a time when intersectionality has been made a kind of bête noire by the political right — see its prominent inclusion earlier in this benighted year on a list of terms that would lead to the immediate denial of applications for potential, and possible cancellation of existing, government grants — it is both refreshing and heartening to dive into a text that embraces it so wholeheartedly.
This work emerged from Walker’s doctoral dissertation, while also indebted to the 2019 Pitt School of Social Work report “Pittsburgh’s Inequality Across Gender and Race,” that concluded for Black women, Pittsburgh might be the worst city in America.
The accounts of Black women in Pittsburgh, though, might initially belie this observation. As Walker notes, there’s a long history of organization and mobilization in the Black community, often led by women. But that is not enough in a city where Black women are traditionally overlooked for leadership positions.
What will be of value in “Rhetoric, Intersectionality, and Black Women in Pittsburgh” is Walker’s scholarship, which is extensive and offers an excellent reading list to anyone interested in academic and non-academic writings about intersectionality, rhetorical and otherwise.
Are Black women in Pittsburgh an example or a subject? This book states “Yes.” However imprecise, Walker’s argument is well-grounded, well thought out, and often dealt with in ways that lead to needless difficulty — an echo of the experiences of Black women in Pittsburgh.
Michael Hodges writes poems, fiction and reviews. Their first published book was “An Idea of Feathers.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.