Given how important mystery is to a “whodunit” thriller like “A Killer Wedding” by Joan O’Leary, it is ironic how familiar these stories can be. The details around the tragic inciting incident are open questions, yet any fan of the genre will find this debut novel hitting all the expected beats. That’s not a bad thing.
Big twists, sudden-yet-inevitable betrayals, deep secrets, and shady, unlikeable characters are all vital ingredients for this storytelling formula. “A Killer Wedding” may not be a stunning shocker that reinvents the form, but it doesn’t need to be. Rather it excels because it reminds readers that the answer to the big question or questions is often less important than the journey that uncovers them.
The setting is a grand castle in the Irish countryside, rented for a wedding by the Ripton family, whose wealth can only be described as mythical. The death of matriarch Gloria just before her grandson’s nuptials presents a big problem for the family.
Christine, the book’s protagonist, is a writer for a bridal magazine who fought to cover this event. As the family tries to cover up the murder, Christine gets a much bigger story than she expected, or that her editors even want. Still, she chases down the truth both in an effort to salvage her assignment and get justice for the murdered woman.
While Christine is the protagonist, author O’Leary uses multiple point-of-view characters to tell its story. Flashbacks illuminate who the people are in the orbit of this rich, unscrupulous family. The ultimate truth is a shock, but whether it delivers a satisfying ending depends on what each reader may want. O’Leary cleverly serves up a tidy resolution, but one that leaves plenty for readers to think about and discuss once they close the book.
The various characters are the high point of the novel, with each member of the family and wedding party intriguing the reader in their own right. They are a captivating and, at times, distasteful group of people, which serves to keep the pages turning.
The overall plot that drives the investigation, coverup and climax is somewhat convoluted — the kind of master plan that only makes sense in fiction. It’s not for the readers who like their mysteries to feel grounded and authentic. Yet it is nonetheless earned because of the colorful, and delightfully cartoonish, people at the center of it.
Murder, especially motivated by money, can be a dark, unsettling topic, which can also be part of the appeal for stories like this. O’Leary keeps the tension and stakes high, yet the plot itself retains a lightness and humor that becomes less surprising when readers realize O’Leary spent time working as a producer on “The Tonight Show.” Even when characters’ lives are at risk, “A Killer Wedding” isn’t scary or terrifying. It’s a crime-solving adventure replete with secret passageways, ulterior motives and everything else people love from a whodunit.
The multiple points-of-view are spread throughout the book in shorter chapters, that help with the pacing. One might read a few chapters before bed intending to read the bulk of it on a flight or at the beach, and the next thing they know they’ve been reading for hours.
O’Leary tells a gripping story with lively characters readers can root for (or against). I was, perhaps, dissatisfied that I did not get more. Readers may share my desire to see the denouement from every character’s point-of-view, but that only speaks to O’Leary’s power as a storyteller. “A Killer Wedding” delivers on all the premises of a good “whodunnit,” and the family at its center promises some deadly fun.
Joshua M. Patton is a father, veteran and senior writer for Comic Book Resources, and his latest short story collection “Tales of Adventure & Fantasy: Giant-Sized!” is available online.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.