How far would you go to get a degree? When Alice Law and her academic rival, Peter Murdoch, graduate students in Magic at Cambridge University, find their advisor, Professor Jacob Grimes, dead, they barely hesitate before researching how to work their way to hell to find him. After all, they still need him to write their recommendations.
“Katabasis,” by R.F. Kuang, is a deep and hilarious dive into the self-important world of academia. Her previous novel, “Babel,” also took place within a magical college, but this book goes far deeper, as our protagonists study Dante, Orpheus and every other previous visitor to the underworld, catalyzing their discoveries into a journey through a hell they find simultaneously inscrutable and all too familiar.
Hell is an impossible space, composed of too many perspectives and viewpoints, mashed together into an amalgam of suffering the human soul can scarcely make it through intact. But academia has left the protagonists, especially Alice, uniquely prepared for this exhausting journey:
“Fortunately graduate school had prepared her for this, the constant managing of despair. Everything was always falling apart; nothing in lab went right; you couldn’t afford groceries, your cottage had a rat problem, all your instructors hated you, you were always one step away from flushing all your life’s work down the toilet. You shoved it to the side of your mind and went to sleep and deferred it all to tomorrow when your brain again functioned well enough to pretend.”
In “Katabasis,” academia is not confined to the external world — its claws dig deeply into Kuang’s vision of hell as well. The afterlife is not composed solely of bones, fire and gnashing teeth — though you’ll find plenty of them here. Instead, Hell opens itself only to those who have deeply researched it, who have learned its impossible contours through endless late nights of study.
The academics walk its surface next to the book’s most fascinating creatures, the Shades, who are the rightful denizens of hell, the infinity of fallen human souls, tasked with laboring their way out of one of Dante’s circles.
While these souls find themselves cast into hell for the most classic of sins, their fate of some rests on an unknown other’s judgment of their best philosophical essay, a constantly rejected thesis of their soul.
The Shades argue continuously and bitterly over their theses, desperately searching for a leg up despite their competition being only themselves.The graduate students can relate — the parallels are truly endless, and the sins all too familiar. Some favorites:
“Self-published self-help productivity books.” “Recites pi to show off.” “Likes to remind people that Dartmouth is in the Ivy League.” “Made his wife call him Doctor.”
Kuang’s hell is not just academic — it’s a work of art. Kuang is a master of creating fully realized universes with fully coherent rules, something not every fantasy writer does well. In many books, the magic “makes sense” only if it is not looked at too hard, only if it is not scrutinized.
“Katabasis” cares deeply about the act of study, and its magic is deeply grounded in chalk, paradox, and belief — and opens the door to a hell that is at once impossible, Escherian, and coherent. Kuang is an author who has thought through the details, who rewards careful readers rather than leaving their concerns ignored.
“Katabasis” is an easy read — and a rewarding one. Both Alice Law and Peter Murdoch are engrossing characters in their own ways, and both grow increasingly complex as the book moves forward.
Their struggles, though foreign to all but the most committed academics (and to those who have found themselves journeying through hell), are deeply human. It’s worth every step into the unknown.
Jesse Welch is a poet, father and software engineer. He co-edited the book “In the Shadow of the Mic: Three Decades of Slam Poetry in Pittsburgh.” His previous review was “Becky Chambers provides the destination.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.