There is a forgotten, uniting thread underpinning virtually all of Europe and parts of Asia. The languages spoken by 42% of human beings alive today — English, French, Spanish, German, Ukrainian, Gaelic, Pashto, Greek, Bengali, and so many more — all possess a shared root in the lost language Proto-Indo-European (PIE).
“Proto: How One Ancient Language Went Global” by Laura Spinney tells the life story of this language and its descendants, a story that begins before the existence of cities and continues to this day.
“Proto” is an unusual book — a detailed biography of a lost language, following scientists in an array of fields, each applying advanced techniques and painstakingly detailed puzzling to reconstruct the history of this language, as well as much of the language itself.
The most obvious researchers involved are the linguists. By analyzing modern and historical languages of which we have records, linguists are able to identify patterns in grammar and sound that see words transform, become adopted, and often disappear. The theoretical PIE word “*hek’wos” lies at the root of the English horse “horse,” through its German etymology. But it’s also the root of the Greek “hippos,” the Latin “equus,” and countless other variants.
Linguistics alone may be able to reconstruct much of the lost details, but “Proto” remains focused on the history of the people who spoke them rather than the words themselves. Archaeology plays a major role in the investigation, allowing the reader to understand the metallurgic sophistication, housing density, and diets of long gone people. This allows us to dive deep into the megalithic proto-cities of the Copper Age, an often forgotten period of human history that predates the transition to the Bronze Age.
But the real star of the show is paleogenetics, the field focused on understanding the genetic relationships of our long gone ancestors. While an individual’s DNA may provide some interesting information about them, DNA taken en masse can tell truly incredible stories about populations as they develop.
By analyzing the DNA of large burial sites in key regions, “they have detected taboos on elites marrying beneath themselves and segregation between ethnic groups. They have picked up genetic signals of fostering, compassion for the disabled, human sacrifice, genocide, and plague. They have determined the scale and in some cases the speed of migrations which archaeologists had only observed in freeze frames. Above all, they have confirmed beyond reasonable doubt the huge role that migration has played in the story of humanity and its languages.”
A particular area these paleogeneticists (and archaeologists and linguists) have focused on is the Eurasian Steppe, particularly in the Ukraine. This is widely considered the homeland of the early Proto-Indo-European language, where the Yamnaya people likely spoke it natively before their migrations spread it through Eurasia.
Even this inherently non-political book cannot avoid wading into the waters of 2025, as research in this critical area has been all but halted due to the ongoing war in Ukraine.
The book itself is a statement of clear support and love for the hard work of real science, and the constant willingness of diligent scientists to reconsider their beliefs and biases.
While media talking heads, politicians, and the Ancient Aliens crowd all accuse the establishment of being unwilling to accept original thinking, “Proto” tells the tale of Marija Gimbutas, who pushed ceaselessly against the grain of archaeological thought for the steppe-first theory of Proto-Indo-European originating in the Ukraine.
Her hypothesis slowly converted the field as more and more evidence was uncovered, until even her fiercest critics were forced to declare her correct.
“Proto” tells the story of a massive portion of humanity, as best as it can be told. It merges the muddy waters of three fields of study and explores the un- and under-documented pre- and early historical eras of Eurasia — and comes out with quite the spectacular tale.
Jesse Welch is a poet, father and software engineer. He co-edited the book “In the Shadow of the Mic: Three Decades of Slam Poetry in Pittsburgh.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.