While Alison Gaylin has a baker’s dozen of novels that precede “We Are Watching,” the novel has the energy of, if not a debut novelist, then one still deeply awed at the form. Storytelling, like any artistry, requires daring. Someone imagines a thing, and not only are they compelled to make it real, it must be shared.

Young writers like to break or avoid the rules, often at their peril, and in this conspiracy thriller tinged with horror, Gaylin tells a story that seems to disregard the conventions of the genre. But her risks pay off, revealing her practiced ease at wielding the tools to keep readers entertained, and, more importantly, turning the page.

One way Gaylin keeps the reader pleasantly on edge is by shifting perspectives. Meg Russo is the protagonist, and the inciting incident is a scenario that’s so horrifying because it feels so plausible, increasingly so in the world today: While driving with her family, a car full of skinheads menaces them on the road, causing an accident that kills her husband Justin.

The grief that consumes Meg would be enough to sustain the story on its own. But she’s also a mother: Lily is a musical prodigy and ready to start her college career at Ithaca, but her father’s death renders her a bright light dimmed before the peak of its luminescence by the vulgar carelessness of people who get off on hate and creating fear.

Advertise with us

At The Secret Garden, the bookstore Meg and Justin once ran together, the story shifts as a group of conspiracy theorists harass and taunt her. A woman named Claire posts a video speaking the title of the book, telling Meg some ominous “we” are watching them.

Claire threatens Meg and her father Nathan, whose own devolution into paranoia and conspiracy theory serve to tantalize the reader with another seemingly coincidental connection, while giving Meg justification to continue to write off these strange events. Gaylin incorporates social media and the way conspiracy theory can thrive online, while also providing avenues for anonymous trolls to harass people with threats. While the cult-like group Claire is just a part of seems absurd, the reality of the danger they pose soon becomes impossible to deny.

The way Gaylin ties these experiences to the characters’ emotions is what helps “We Are Watching” feel unpredictable and unique. She also seems invested in the nature of art. Nathan is an aging musician from a band called Prism, who had a hit and then faded into obscurity. Meg herself published a novel as a younger woman, called “Prophesy.” While its sales were modest and its impact forgettable, the cult that targets her family are, in a twisted way, big fans of the work. This drives much of the conflict.

The story starts off slowly, as the reader gets to know the myriad characters and their connections. Gaylin plays with point-of-view, allowing the parent-child relationships to take shape. Meg and Lily are the emotional foundation of the book, but Nathan’s relationship with her is equally informative in the way every parent’s style is either an attempt to emulate or reject the way they were raised. A little more than midway through the book, the pacing speeds up and then never slows down.

Alison Gaylin could have otherwise titled “We Are Watching” as “Prophesy,” after Meg’s book. The focus on social media, conspiracy theory, ideological echo chambers and how this can manifest into real world harm feels even more prescient now than just a year ago. Truth is not what it used to be, and even seasoned readers will sometimes wonder what is and is not real.

Advertise with us

Yet, in this case, facts aren’t nearly as important as feelings. The authenticity of the characters are what grabs the reader and doesn’t let go. Richly-drawn relationships, specifically between parent and child, take the idea of feeling “seen” in fiction and push into the more frightful territory of being watched.

Joshua M. Patton is a father, veteran and senior writer for Comic Book Resources, and his latest short story collection “Tales of Adventure & Fantasy: Giant-Sized!” is available online.

A previous version of this review misstated a plot point. It is protagonist Meg’s husband who dies in the novel, not her daughter. We regret the error.