In my youthful days, I once convinced a friend who’d never seen a Star Wars movie to join me at “Episode III: Revenge of the Sith” — the sixth of the series to be released — at a cinema in Brooklyn. In many ways, she was the ideal viewer, perhaps the only person in the theatre shocked by a big, if long-time coming, reveal at the end. But on our way out, she said, “So, now I need you to explain, uh, everything.”
I felt something similar as I read Jesse Q. Sutanto’s charming new novel, the second in her Vera Wong series. I was slightly lost from the opening pages, when a large cast of characters assembled, who apparently first appeared in the prior book, “Vera Wong’s Unsolicited Advice for Murderers,” which I have not read. At first, reading the mystery felt like wandering into a wedding reception where everyone was friendly, but I didn’t know a soul.
Thankfully, in time, the plot settled into something more Vera-centric, as she insists on inserting herself into another investigation, after bumping into Millie, a distraught young immigrant woman. Millie is lurking around the police station, waffling on whether to file a police report about a friend of hers who has gone missing.
Soon it’s revealed that her friend, an influencer named Xander Lin, is not just missing, but dead, possibly murdered. Through prying, snooping, and plying various people with various dumplings, Vera soon uncovers a complex case that takes the rest of the book to unravel.
Vera is a hoot. She simply will not mind her own business, and while the book attributes that tenacity to her Chinese heritage and upbringing, anyone who’s experienced (or had) that “Nevertheless, she persisted” vibe will relate.
I especially relished her takedown of an officious school principal who simply could not withstand a Vera assault. And it’s just plain fun to read how she angers her son’s girlfriend Selena, a police detective, both by investigating the murder, and by insisting on calling Selena her daughter-in-law. In a cozy mystery like this one, the mild irritation Vera causes is a delicious thread that enlivens the safe narrative.
Less deliciously, the book is overstuffed with characters. Sutanto takes pains to include those I met at the beginning throughout the novel. Occasionally, this takes some vehement shoehorning. Perhaps some of these folks need to drop out of the narrative before the fifth Vera Wong book has a cast of thousands.
Even less delicious for me were the ways that Vera felt a bit stereotypical. I didn’t love her constant malapropisms, nor the way English seemed to be a struggle for her at times. And how did she afford to produce what must have been a metric ton of Chinese food over the course of the novel? Her flour budget alone must be in the thousands.
I’m on firmer ground feeling uneasy about how Xander’s disappearance (and Millie’s reluctance) end up tying back to human trafficking. Sutanto provides an interesting explanation after the novel about how this issue came to her attention, and how deeply she researched it for the book.
Indeed, her rigor shows: the sections of the plot that touch on it, in ways I don’t wish to spoil, are grim and convincing — and tonally out of sync with the pleasant and cheerful vibe of the rest of the book. I still can’t decide if I wanted Vera to be a little bit more hard-boiled, or if I wanted the mystery she finagles her way into to be a little less intense. Right now, it’s as if Anne of Green Gables took on the mafia.
By the end, the cast of the old book is folded into the cast of the new book, and everyone parties together amicably — children and adults, teens and crooks, all happy to eat Vera’s food and serve as her found family. There’s not a second of it that feels realistic, and there’s also not a chance I wouldn’t accept the invitation to that party if asked.
Live long, Vera Wong!
Shannon Reed is a teaching associate professor at the University of Pittsburgh, and, most recently, the author of “Why We Read: On Bookworms, Libraries and Just One More Page Before Lights Out.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.