
Land is power. And It is only through understanding how societies have wielded power through land, Michael Albertus urges in “Land Power: Who Has It, Who Doesn’t, And How That Determines the Fate of Societies,” that we can hope to address the social inequities of the past, change our world for the better now, and create a better future for us all.
The primary strengths of “Land Power” lie in its astonishing breadth, global reach, and the clarity with which Albertus breaks down the history of land acquisition and redistribution. This breadth is not surprising. Albertus is a professor of Political Science at the University of Chicago and “Land Power” is his third monograph on the political and economic influence of land.
The author’s illumination of complex ideas creates a highly readable experience for a general audience without sacrificing nuance. The book is not theory-heavy or laden with academic jargon. Instead, its foundation lies in Albertus’ decades of field work, interviews, and studies around the world.
LAND POWER: WHO HAS IT, WHO DOESN’T, AND HOW THAT DETERMINES THE FATE OF SOCIETIES
Michael Albertus
Basic Books / Hachette ($30)
This ground-level engagement is “Land Power”’s greatest appeal. The book is organized into three sections that create an accessible through-line — the history of land, the problems with land, and land as an integral solution for those problems. Albertus grounds the problem with land as “Great Reshuffles” — the invention and proliferation of agriculture, as well as the rise of nation-states and colonialism, which served to consolidate land, and thereby economic and political power, into the hands of a few.
Albertus addresses the way in which this reshuffling of land led to our greatest global problems: racism, sexism, environmental degradation, and economic underdevelopment. The author draws from a wide range of historical and contemporary case studies, like his examination of the Aqua Caliente Band of Cahuilla Indians, and considers how settlers produced and sustained racialist categories.
In Canada, by contrast, he highlights legal barriers that barred women from owning homesteaded land, leading to a legacy of gendered inequality that continues to this day. Other case studies in West Bengal and El Salvador help complicate how social inequalities have arisen in differing ways through the appropriation and distribution of property.
The most complex and fascinating examples are when Albertus describes how various 20th century global political upheavals led to populist land redistribution and the lasting environmental and economic repercussions of those varied reallocations. In sections on China, Russia, Brazil, Mexico, Venezuela, and Post-War Italy, he effectively highlights the political tool land has so often become, often to the detriment of the people who live on that land and on the land itself.
He also considers land reallocation as a powerful tool for economic and social prosperity into the future, delving into the importance of property rights to economic development in Peru, a strong rule of law and rigorous record keeping in Bolivia, prioritizing women’s land titling in Colombia, re-wilding movements that seek to protect land in Chile and Spain, and land reparations that have returned land to Black and Indigenous people in South Africa and Australia.
The examples work well to ground social movements that might seem ambitious or even utopian in political and economic frameworks that have been and continue to be successful, if not without their flaws. This is a refreshing and concrete ending that leaves the reader believing not just how crucial land is for global social justice, but that it is possible to reallocate land in peaceful, successful, egalitarian ways.
To detail this breadth in so little space (the book clocks in at just over 250 pages), Albertus must give up a certain amount of complexity. For example, the influence of institutions like the World Bank and International Monetary Fund on land redistribution and economic development often downplay or fail to address the real social and economic problems to which those institutions have contributed.
Still — “Land Power” manages to succeed as both an ambitious and accessible argument for the importance of a broad and global understanding of land as central to wielding power as well as the ways in which that power can be utilized to build a better world in the future.
Jennifer A. Howard is a fiction writer and academic who lives in Durham, NC.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.