
“The Good Mother Myth” isn’t just a book to make pregnant women and current mothers feel better, although those people will find a lot within these pages, including Nancy Reddy’s relatable experience of feeling like a failure as a mother, the origins of our ideas about what makes a mother good, and the shaky science underpinning the current maternal zeitgeist.
There’s plenty of reassurance among the aftershocks of Reddy’s research. But these lessons about motherhood, and how to identify the criticisms we’ve internalized about good and bad motherhood, are for everyone.
THE GOOD MOTHER MYTH
By Nancy Reddy
St. Martin’s Press ($28)
In fact, one of the strongest messages of the book applies to all of the non-mothers out there caring for children, whether they be adopted parents, gay parents, grandparents, neighbors, or the proverbial villagers needed to raise a child. It turns out that love grows — meaning that you’re not a freak if you don’t feel an immediate, innate, overpowering connection to the screaming baby who doesn’t seem to care that you’re at your wits end.
Love grows with the attention and care given, and therefore does not require a biological mother’s connection to an infant to be just as strong and fulfilling. Reddy explains how mothering does not come naturally to many moms, which breeds sentiments of failure, but caring for a child is a skill like any other, requiring practice.
Everything that a “good” mom knows how to do, from soothing to feeding to entertaining a child, she has to learn, which means that all the non-birthing caregivers out there can learn it too. It’s a heartening message.
Even readers with no infants in their lives have something to learn about attachment theory. A widely popular way to make sense of our interpersonal relationships with adult parents and romantic partners alike, attachment theory and its labels of anxious, avoidant, and secure attachment live in the common vernacular today.
Most people do not know, though, that this theory was developed in studying monkeys in a lab, in “studies… riddled with errors and bias, sloppy sampling, and methodological shortcomings.” Meaning that these monkeys, who were given the choice between a warm cloth cylinder and a cold wire frame, have little bearing on the conclusion that mothers must be available to their babies 24/7/365 to raise independent, confident offspring who will similarly mother their own children.
Then, to see how these shoddy results have been applied to humankind, without any real basis for comparison between species, makes clear all the ways that attachment theory baldly reinforces the ideals of post-war America for middle-class, white mothers — who should really be wearing heels and housedresses in the kitchen and preparing nutritious food for their families.
In other words, “you might feel like you’re anxiously attached, in the same way you feel like you’re a Libra… and that might help you understand how you move through the world — but that doesn’t make it science.”
Reddy has researched both the science and the scientists, pointing out both their methods and their hypocrisy. Many of the authorities on motherhood in the twentieth century weren’t mothers but fathers, whose wives often participated in their research and received no academic or professional credit for it. More importantly, many of these men at the forefront of the research telling mothers what a bad job they’ve been doing for the last 80 years did not practice the type of parenting they preached.
History lessons are woven in with criticisms of decades-old studies and Reddy provides some comic relief and real-world examples in anecdotes from her own life as a mother of two. Reddy offers new perspectives on our futures, whether or not we have or want kids, and our pasts, reframing the advice our parents and grandparents were getting about mothering that shaped the way we grew up.
“The Good Mother Myth” is a must-read for anyone with expectations regarding motherhood.
Kaitlyn Shirey is an engineer and writer from Westmoreland County.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.