
Set between New York City and a fishing village in County Donegal, Ireland, Catherine Airey’s polyphonic debut novel, “Confessions,” follows the story of three generations of Irish women, each of whom struggles to not only understand herself, but also to overcome the wounds of inherited trauma.
While multiple generations are given voice in the novel, the heart of the story lies in the relationship between two sisters, Máire and Róisín Dooley. They grow up in a rural community, on a dairy farm, and while Máire demonstrates some concerning traits — she sees statues move in church and is sometimes truly cruel to her younger sister — their lives seem to be set on a safe if predictable course.
CONFESSIONS
By Catherine Airey
Mariner Books ($30)
However, things change with the sudden death of their father. Not only have they lost the economic security he provided, their mother’s reaction to her husband’s passing is to stop speaking. Not a word, ever again. Mother and daughters must leave the family home for estate housing and the children become caregivers to their remaining parent. Their only outlet in the face of these sad circumstances is Máire’s art and Róisín’s writing.
At the same time, a group of women committed to living a communal life have moved into an abandoned Protestant boarding school in the village, calling themselves the Atlantis Primal Therapy Commune. Among their many ideas is that “you could release demons from your past by screaming.”
Not only is the community intrigued by this, but it truly shows the vibrancy of Airey’s imagination. The women come from all over Ireland. Poverty? Abusive, deadbeat husband? Secret abortion? Or simply living a life of quiet desperation? No problem, everyone is welcome to scream away their anxiety and fear and rage in a safe and supportive environment.
The Screamers, as the locals call them, know they are out of touch with the parochial culture of village life. But that’s the point, they’re offering women who don’t fit into traditional ideas of femininity to discover who they might become under different circumstances.
Not surprisingly, the sisters are interested in the commune. And when Máire’s artistic talent blossoms, she leaves — with the Screamer’s help — to study art at NYU. The writing about art as aesthetic pleasure, as therapy, and as social activism is one of the novel’s highpoints.
At this point the reader might be excused for thinking they’ve been set up for an immigrant success story. But New York is notorious for crushing as many dreams as it encourages, especially when you bring your own troubles with you.
For a book as reliant on plot as “Confessions,” it would be unfair to spoil the pleasures of Airey’s sprawling narrative. Máire falls into many of the traps that afflict young artists, some of them truly harrowing. Her art helps her, but it ultimately doesn’t offer a way out. At one point she thinks, “You cannot bear it, the world’s relentless realness.”
The result affects not only Máire, but everyone she knows. Her sister, daughter, and granddaughter, however, suffer worst of all. The enigma of Máire’s life in New York comes to haunt them, and so often they look for the secrets and ghosts of that life to explain the damage to their own.
There is a danger in all polyphonic novels: some characters are simply more compelling than others. That is true of “Confessions.” The voices of the younger generations, especially, are tepid compared to the sections written from Máire and Róisín’s point-of-view.
Still, “Confessions” is an engaging and thought-provoking debut. Especially when Airey gives the most significant idea of the novel to Róisín, who in a letter to her sister writes, “We’re only as sick as our secrets.”
Róisín provides an invitation to Máire, and all the characters, to confess. Only in telling those secrets, the novel seems to say, does the world offer even the possibility of eliminating trauma and outrunning the shadows of the past.
Jeffrey Condran is the author of the story collection “Claire, Wading into the Danube By Night” and is the co-founder and publisher of the independent literary press Braddock Avenue Books.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.