John Grisham, best-known for such best-selling legal fiction as “The Firm” and “The Pelican Brief,” teams up with Centurion Ministries founder Jim McCloskey on “Framed,” a searing reminder of the mistakes, both deliberate and inadvertent, that lead to wrongful imprisonment in our country’s deeply flawed penal system.

Grisham and McCloskey wrote five chapters each. Both keep their language lean and their narrative straightforward — the stories of the unjustly convicted are enough.

Grisham sits on the board of Centurion, an organization devoted to freeing the wrongly imprisoned. He dedicates this infuriating, necessary book to founders of the Innocence Project, which uses DNA evidence to free those jailed through phony forensic methods marshaled to support an authoritarian, cruel brand of justice. McCloskey, a first-person narrator as a figure in several of these accounts, dedicates this work to several Centurion colleagues.

FRAMED

Advertise with us

By John Grisham and Jim McCloskey

Doubleday ($30)

“In 1976, the U.S. Supreme Court lifted a four-year ban on executions,” Grisham writes in a chapter about Calder Todd Willingham, an Oklahoma native “executed for a crime that never occurred.”

“Since then, 1,572 men and 15 women have been put to death by gas, lethal injection, electric chair, and one by hanging and another by firing squad. Texas proudly leads the pack with 586 killings, Oklahoma is second with 123, barely edging out Virginia with 113.”

The northernmost case, a Grisham story, takes place in Chester, the oldest town in Pennsylvania. But, most of these cautionary tales unfold in Texas, where justice seems more cudgel than corrective. Grisham and McCloskey suggest that malfeasance along the spectrum of criminal (in)justice seems particularly common in the South.

Advertise with us

“The Norfolk Four,” the chapter that opens the book, painstakingly recounts the byzantine process that finally resulted in the exoneration of four men wrongfully convicted for a 1997 rape and murder, who finally went free after 20 years in prison.

What’s particularly scandalous is that authorities built a fictitious case against four innocent men — after the actual murderer confessed, and DNA backed his confession. Omar Ballard insisted he acted alone, and he had prior convictions for violent attacks on women.

His personal history and demeanor corroborated his confession. As Grisham’s wrote: “He went from one foster home to another and naturally gravitated to the streets from where he came. He was an angry kid who blamed his mother for his problems. His temper was explosive and often aimed at women.”

Another story resonates because it involves Dracos Burke, the cousin of James Lee Burke, the great mystery writer known for his Dave Robicheaux books. Attorney Dracos Burke was the prosecutor in the murder case of a grocery store owner in New Iberia, a small town in southern Louisiana. Given the case’s outcome, McCloskey does not paint Dracos Burke in a kindly light.

One of the most lurid stories — and the book’s longest chapter — unfolds in Tyler, a town in the heart of the Texas Bible Belt. On June 10, 1977, when Eastern University secretary Paula Rudolph returned to her apartment, she encountered a man she assumed was a dean from her work, Jim Mayfield, who had been having an affair with Linda Jo Edwards, her roommate. Rudolph soon went to bed.

Advertise with us

The following morning, Rudolph discovered Edwards brutally murdered and mutilated. Although DNA evidence clearly points to Mayfield as the killer, Kerry Max Cook, a neighbor of the two women, continues to wait for the Criminal Court of Appeals, the highest court in Texas, to vacate his conviction.

These stories are sad and shameful. Their blend of public service and call to action — and their draw as true-life pulp fiction — will inform, infuriate and, one can only hope, inspire.

Update, Sept. 29, 2024: This version corrects the first name of author Jim McCloskey.

Carlo Wolff is a writer from Cleveland.