
Imagine a world where dinosaurs never existed — or, rather, where we had no knowledge of their existence. How different would our understanding of Earth’s history be? In “Dinosaurs at the Dinner Party,” science writer and historian Edward Dolnick explores the profound impact of 19th-century dinosaur discoveries on science, religion and our perception of time itself.
Dolnick’s narrative begins with early-19th-century fossil discoveries: a young boy stumbling upon giant bones in Massachusetts and Mary Anning, a poor, uneducated woman who pulled countless fossils from the cliffs of her seaside town in England. Anning, crucially, understood the scientific magnitude of what she’d found.
DINOSAURS AT THE DINNER PARTY: HOW AN ECCENTRIC GROUP OF VICTORIANS DISCOVERED PREHISTORIC CREATURES AND ACCIDENTALLY UPENDED THE WORLD
By Edward Dolnick
Scribner ($30)
For millennia, people understood such strange findings through myths and legends. Citing historian Adrienne Mayor, Dolnick highlights examples like the dragon, likely inspired by early European dinosaur fossil finds, or the Greek cyclops myth, probably stemming from giant ancient elephant skulls: The hole for the trunk looked to ancient Greeks be one giant eye socket. The griffin that terrified ancient traders crossing the Gobi Desert looks very much like Protoceratops fossils found scattered across the Gobi.
Even in early modernity, Gottfried Leibniz, one of the most brilliant thinkers of the 17th century, thought he and Otto von Guericke had discovered a unicorn. “The unicorn story is noteworthy,” Dolnick writes, “not because Leibniz and von Guericke went wrong, but because it highlights how immensely difficult it was to reconstruct unknown animals from a collection of bones. Unicorn-style blunders were nearly inevitable.”
Nineteenth-century Europe, however, saw a convergence of rationalism, industrialization, and the height of European colonialism. Colonial explorers delivered ever-more exotic wonders, extracted and put on display in gilded European palaces. Who could say that a unicorn didn’t exist, when the rhinoceros had only recently entered the European imagination?
Meanwhile, industrial activity resulted in more of the Earth being dug up for construction or resource extraction, meaning that more fossils than ever before were discovered. Most scandalously, the work of French scientists paved the way for evolutionary theories.
Charles Lyell’s ideas were particularly provocative: “Humankind had flickered into existence and would flicker out again, Lyell wrote, ‘as ephemeral … as the insects which live but from the rising to the setting of the sun.’”
However, most English scientists of the day were devout Christians, including Richard Owen, who is responsible for the term “dinosaur.” Despite his significant contributions (largely buttressed by Mary Anning’s then-uncredited fossil discoveries), Owen was vehemently opposed to “transmutationism” — an early umbrella term for evolutionary ideas.
The idea that species could emerge and go extinct repeatedly over billions of years contradicted the notion of a perfect, unchanging creation emerging, ex nihilo, from the mouth of God. An accusation of being a transmutationist could doom one’s career. Even Charles Darwin remained carefully in the background until he finally published “On the Origin of Species” at the age of fifty and changed the scientific understanding of biology forever.
Dolnick’s argument hinges on the idea that the reactionary religiosity of Owen and other scientists of his day passed with the 19th century. This seems like wishful thinking. Religious belief may now be uncommon among scientists, but it still influences contemporary scientific thought. Perhaps the most famous example is Kurt P. Wise, a Harvard-educated geologist who, despite his rigorous scientific training, adheres to a young-earth creationist view.
But if we peer beyond the ivory tower, religion remains significant. Globally, more people are still religious than not — 83%, as estimated by the Pew Research Center in 2012 — and believe in cosmologies founded more on magic than evidence. Here in the United States, evangelical Christianity has become a shibboleth for the traditionalist right, and progressivism retains many echoes of Christian and Jewish religious thought.
“Dinosaurs at the Dinner Party” is an illuminating exploration of the discoveries of dinosaurs and the confused, messy attempts of scientists and laypeople to understand the meaning of these prehistoric behemoths. But the broad assumption underpinning Dolnick’s argument, that the discovery of dinosaurs turned humanity away from our superstitions, is almost as fanciful as believing in a world created by the whispers of gods.
Joshua D. Graber is a writer and software engineer from Pittsburgh.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.