
Why do we tell each other scary stories? Celebrated horror author Stephen Graham Jones believes it’s because they make the world a bigger place by expanding the borders of what is real. In the foreword to “Never Whistle at Night: An Indigenous Dark Fiction Anthology,” he writes that Native authors are particularly good at telling scary stories because they’ve been steeped in the horrors of colonization for five hundred years.
What makes Indigenous dark fiction so different from typical genre fare is that it is often hopeful, with inconclusive endings that point toward a future in which Native people might just call this place theirs again. This hopefulness gives many of the 26 stories in the anthology a kind of trickster energy and humor that lightens even the most grotesque body horror and macabre colonialist hauntings.
NEVER WHISTLE AT NIGHT: AN INDIGENOUS DARK FICTION ANTHOLOGY
Edited by Shane Hawk and Theodore C. Van Alst Jr.
Vintage ($17)
Surprising range
The anthology is packed with award-winning authors like Cherie Dimaline (Georgian Bay Metis), Tommy Orange (Cheyenne and Arapahoe), Brandon Hobson (Cherokee), and Kelli Jo Ford (Cherokee). Their literary style brings a surprising range to classical horror genre subjects even as they immerse the reader in contemporary Native issues.
In their able hands, oversized blood-sucking ticks are the consequences of cutting oneself off from Indigenous land practices and traditions, and Native ghosts rise up time and again to seek revenge on settler enemies. They also extend the borders of horror by calling attention to the unsettling nature of everyday life, such as when one protagonist begins to believe the new translation of his book is possessed, and another must defend himself from a new lover who has taken over his beach house with his collection of (maybe) human teeth.
The anthology also includes a wide range of burgeoning and amateur writers. What these writers may lack in polish they more than make up for with refreshingly creepy takes on well-worn and often appropriated topics such as Wendigos and other Native monsters, spells and curses, and “Indian” graveyards.
Where the anthology really shines is when it grapples with complex representational issues. In one story, the protagonist must choose whether to rid herself of her Nativeness by literally letting her bigoted mother-in-law cut off a pinky finger. In another, a mother is so obsessed with what constitutes Nativeness that she attempts to steal the blood of a full-blooded Native man at his own funeral to inject into her son to increase his cultural belonging.
The horror in these stories often comes from an author pushing on crucial issues like blood quantum, authenticity and Native gatekeeping to explore questions like “What constitutes Nativeness?” and “Who gets to be Native?”
Good medicine
The results often transcend mere genre to become an act of what internationally acclaimed storyteller Richard Van Camp (Tlicho Dene) calls good “medicine.” His contribution “Scariest.Story.Ever” is one of the strongest and most poignant stories in the anthology.
In a bid to win a thousand-dollar prize in a scary story contest, the protagonist visits a town elder whose aunt was renowned for having once told a story so scary that it turned children into adults. He gets more than he bargains for, when the elder turns the story into a moment of cultural recovery, first describing how the scary story once brought his community together and then doing the same for the protagonist and, arguably, the reader.
At its best, the anthology highlights how stories, even scary ones, can heal.
Some readers may be put off by the inclusion of authors who are not enrolled members of Native nations and those who have been called to account recently for their inability to document Native ancestry.
There is also an argument that the anthology could have benefitted from a broader inclusion of Indigenous authors from around the world. Most of the stories are written by members of Native nations residing in the United States, with a few contributions from First Nations people of Canada.
However, for those who choose to overlook those arguments, “Never Whistle at Night” provides a solid grounding in both Indigenous twists on traditional elements of horror, as well as an expansion of what horror means for Native authors.
Jennifer A. Howard is a fiction writer and academic who lives in Durham, NC.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.