The shipboard romance of bandleader-pianist Will Goodman and Lena Aldridge, a jazz thrush mulling the next step in her career, is the on-ramp for “Harlem After Midnight,” the second installment in Louise Hare’s Canary Club Mystery series. Soaked in atmospheric detail conjuring the Harlem of the early 20th century, this take on that fabled neighborhood weaves issues that still resonate into a whodunnit that keeps the reader on the hunt.
The book certainly starts dramatically: A woman falls from the third-floor window of an apartment where there’s a party. Nobody sees her fall. Is it an attempted murder or an accident? Will she survive?
Ms. Hare, a British author who is multi-racial, like her protagonist, front-loads the book with clues about the woman who fell, showing what a New York City cop saw. From the first page:
“His eyes traced along to her face. So beautiful and still, her cheek resting against the cold step, her hair curling down toward the sidewalk. Her eyes were closed, her face serene, as if she had just fallen asleep, though the rest of her body was in chaos, sprawled upside down with legs twisted and one foot almost kicking the front door of the building.”
Along the way to solving the mystery, Ms. Hare crafts a fascinating tale of self-discovery involving her main characters. And in the relationship between Lena’s aunt and the rich white man Tar, she paints a picture of a time when the power dynamics of racism were more overt than today.
The novel bounces between 1936, when Lena is the narrator and focus, and 1908 when we follow her father, Alfie. There are other dualities and contrasts: New York and London, and above all, black and white. Not to mention concerns like family, loyalty and faith.
Lena’s story begins on the Queen Mary, headed for New York to perform in a Broadway show, when she learns the show is canceled. She decides she might as well spend some time in New York, where she may be able to ferret out information about Alfie and his sister Jessie, both vanished years ago.
Her budding affair with Will, who’s taking a break from his shipboard gig, lands her in the home of Claudette and Louis Linfield, Will’s relatives, for the time Lena plans to spend in New York. Will, meanwhile, aims to spend the time with Lena to see how deep their feelings for each other might go.
Thanks to the connections of the Linfields and Will’s reputation as a ragtime virtuoso, Will and Lena wind up enjoying Harlem’s Jazz Age nightlife and earn a spot on the Apollo Theater’s Amateur Night.
Early on, Lena meets Will’s half-sister Bel, a bartender and single mother trying to do more than get by. Bel’s relationship with Will is inexplicably cool to Lena. One day, they go shopping. Pretense is part of their strategy, and “passing” is the goal, as Bel fakes Lena’s authentic British accent:
“It was the most fun I’d ever had acting,” Lena recounts. “Bel and I rampaged through ladies’ wear in Bloomingdale’s and Bergdorf Goodman. …Shop assistants tripped up in their eagerness to help these two wealthy young women. The accent seemed to be the key and I was having so much fun that I’d forgotten that there were actually people in New York who knew me …”
Complicated and absorbing, “Harlem After Midnight” operates on many levels. It’s fun, and its story is rich, and even minor characters like Tar, Leon and the Butterworths are deftly crafted. May Hare’s Canary Club Mystery series continue the saga of Lena Aldridge.
Carlo Wolff is a freelance writer from Cleveland. He recently published “Invisible Soul,” a book about Cleveland’s soul music scene from doo-wop to disco.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.