It’s all the fault of “Gone Girl.” Since that page-turner’s massive success in 2012, publishers have ceaselessly flooded the market with thrillers for women readers, often featuring damaged women protagonists who have Big Secrets, plots so twisty you almost get lost in them and a black-and-white cover with a splash of red for effect. Alice Feeney’s latest book, “Good Bad Girl,” is a lesser example of the type.

Ms. Feeney published her first novel, “Sometimes I Lie,” in 2017, and has released six more novels since then, all thrillers. That’s a lot of complicated books to write in six years, and her latest, “Good Bad Girl,” shows the strain of keeping so many mysterious and troubled (but good at heart) characters going in a way that readers can buy. It’ll still sell thousands of copies, but I think Ms. Feeney might want to slow down.

“Good Bad Girl” tells the complicated-to-the-point-of-unbelievable story of several estranged mother-daughter pairs. There’s a murder, though it happens off-stage and to someone we’ve been shown to be morally bankrupt. There’s also an arrest for that murder, of the character who you’ll be absolutely certain did it from the moment they enter the story. Everyone has a secret, which they only reveal out of narrative convenience, usually towards the end of the book. Every character sounds pretty much the same, talking in clichés, along the lines of “Everybody has a mother, but not everyone has a mother’s love.” Don’t even get me started on how overweight and gay characters fare in these parts.

No one is reading thrillers for poetry or photo-realism, it’s true. But Ms. Feeney also fumbles two key elements of thriller writing. She has a tendency to drop dramatic lines that reveal plots points and then sort of … forget about them? Early on, we’re told a character is quitting her job “because they’ll never let her return … once they find out what she’s capable of.” But just a few chapters later, she does return to that job, and there’s no fuss at all. It’s also not clear what she’s capable of, and whether she did anything to show that or not. The sentence existed just to goose the readers, but, in the end, doesn’t deliver.

Advertise with us

Well, Ms. Feeney has to keep us turning the pages. But her competence with time’s passage causes her more problems. The book follows three different main characters, Patience, Frankie and Edith — if I told you how they’re connected, I’d ruin the book, sorry. Ms. Feeney chooses to tell their stories in present tense, over the course of a couple of days. That means she’s obliged to show us pretty much everything they do, explain where each of them is while the other has the stage, and manufacture ways that their lives intersect. The plot slackens when, for example, Frankie and Patience are actually in the same location but must be kept apart for the benefit of the plot’s climax. All three characters are forced to fall asleep or stare thoughtfully out windows for extended periods during what must be the most exciting hours of their lives, just to make it all work.

Of course, it all turns out just fine in the end, and Ms. Feeney shows glints of a more interesting, convincing novel. I think she has a great mystery series in her if she wanted to attempt it. I liked the slightly ridiculous police inspector (who is said to look twenty when she first appears, and then is later revealed to be a twenty-year veteran — sign me up for the pampering life of a British cop, please) and despite it all, I was happy to see various mothers reunited with various daughters by the end. It’s all going to make a bang-up film.

Shannon Reed is teaching assistant professor of creative writing at Pitt and the author of ”Why Did I Get a B? And Other Mysteries We’re Discussing in the Faculty Lounge.”