I kept thinking about the neighbors when reading Prachi Gupta’s searing memoir, “They Called Us Exceptional and Other Lies That Raised Us.” In it, the University of Pittsburgh alumnus recounts a hellish upbringing in her Indian-American family, complete with an abusive, mentally unstable father, a co-dependent mother and a confused, scared little brother, Yush.
All I could consider was how the Guptas must have appeared to their neighbors, friends and relatives: basically normal, with just a little drama now and then. Their efforts were constantly put towards appearing so.
But in fact, their life was a horror show, as Ms. Gupta’s father belittled, threatened and controlled the three of them, damaging his family and, as Ms. Gupta makes clear, putting them all in sometimes mortal peril. I won’t soon forget the scene in which Ms. Gupta’s father, suddenly and irrationally irate in the midst of a calm conversation, smashes a plate across his daughter’s skull.

Ms. Gupta and Yush were expected to be outstanding examples of the benefits of assimilation: Indian-American kids who excelled academically, went to prestigious schools and became doctors or took another occupation suitable to the elite. Ms. Gupta, a former senior reporter at Jezebel, recounts that she failed at this assignment, partially because of how white America looks at brown people. In failing, she did find who she really was, but at the cost of losing her family.
I wasn’t familiar with Ms. Gupta’s award-winning essay, “Stories About My Brother,” which inspired this memoir. I found the conceit, in which Ms. Gupta writes to her mother in the second-person — “Our plan to surprise you was simple” is how she opens — to be a little hokey, reading strangely when Ms. Gupta informed her mother of facts she would surely already know. But gradually, the technique grew on me, as the gulf between the two women widened. It began to make sense that the narrator would need to recount her feelings even to the person who had been in the room, since emotions and differing perspectives were so rarely discussed or examined in their home.
Still, this style of narration makes for a narrow focus, despite often beautiful sentences. It’s rare that any character besides Ms. Gupta and her immediate family command attention, and minor characters drift into cliché (such as a teacher who pops up just long enough to be vaguely racist, a common refrain from all non-familial adults in Ms. Gupta’s youth).
Some more important characters suffer from not being Ms. Gupta’s main interest: a fiancée of several years vaguely drifts into and out of the story, possibly because he seemed to have no issue with how his future father-in-law treated his wife-to-be. But even characters of true substance, such as Ms. Gupta’s surprising grandfather, Dadaji, tend to get little space, in favor of the seemingly endless back and forth relationship she has with her parents.
In the final quarter, though, Ms. Gupta’s purpose tightens, as she chronicles her last attempts to communicate with them, leading up to, and then trying to understand, a familial tragedy. Here, the narrow focus makes the book impossible to put down, a tragi-comedy that provides closure in the harshest of ways. It turns out that Ms. Gupta cannot be a good daughter and her own person, and her choice, while complex and sad, also feels inevitable.
The book exposes the seedy underbelly of what we all consider to be “normal” family dynamics: It turns out that the flip side of a neighbor’s “drama” might be a toxic stew of cruelty, neglect and personality disorders. Someone always seems to be giving the others the silent treatment, and earnest emails are perpetually falling on deaf ears.
I think every reader will come away feeling the book is a powerful consideration of some American evil: racism, xenophobia or exceptionalism. For me, the more powerful indictment is of misogyny, which Ms. Gupta devastatingly portrays as ultimately more painful to the misogynist than to its victim. Her father will have to decide if he can bear to read it.
Shannon Reed is teaching assistant professor of creative writing at Pitt and the author of ”Why Did I Get a B? And Other Mysteries We’re Discussing in the Faculty Lounge.”
Prachi Gupta will be appearing at City of Asylum as a part of their program “Untangling the Roots of the Model Minority Myth” at 7 p.m. Aug. More information is available via Alphabet City.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.