The following is an excerpt from “Brothers: A Memoir of Love, Loss, and Race” (Temple University Press).

The night my grandfather died and my brother lost his right eye, I slept with all the windows open. Spring had come to the Mojave. The air smelled of sagebrush and rain, and tiny gold flowers speckled the dark basalt hills. The desert, for all its austerity, knows how to be grateful. Seeing the first buds of spring, our mother would quote Kahlil Gibran: “The deeper sorrow carves into your being the more joy it can contain.” Maybe that’s why she moved us to the middle of the Mojave, two miles off the paved road, between the dunes and the cracked clay of the dry lake. Our mother found beauty in survival.

She let me sleep through the first call. Her father had been sick a long time; his death brought tears but also relief. The second call brought only terror. My brother, Peter Slate, had been assaulted at a nightclub in Santa Monica. He was a large Black man dancing with a young White woman, and a group of skinheads attacked him. At least, that’s how I understood it then. Years later, I found a more complicated story in the police report. My brother had left the dance floor to put his beer down on a table. He exchanged words with a man sitting at the table. Both had been drinking, and their argument escalated. The man at the table was White, as was the other man who came from behind and smashed a bottle into my brother’s right eye, pushing glass up toward his brain. My family saw the attack as a hate crime, but what role did race play that night?

My brother and I had the same mother, but different fathers. His was from Nigeria. Having a White mother and a White brother complicated his Blackness, but it did not change how he was seen by strangers as he walked down the street, or danced in a club with a White woman. He was Black. I was White, and so were the men who attacked him.

Advertise with us

I was fourteen. My brother, seven years older than me, was my best friend and the closest thing I had to a father. When I was seven and we still lived in the city, the Domino’s Pizza guy was mugged outside our home. We had iron bars over our windows but I was still too scared to sleep. My brother sat by my bed, held my hand, and told me that there was only one tool that could cut through those iron bars. It had a diamond blade that cost thousands of dollars. Even with that special saw, it would still take robbers over three hours to cut through one bar, and the high-pitched squeal of the saw would wake everyone in the neighborhood. I slept deeply from then on.

The sun had risen by the time we reached the hospital, yet the hallways were strangely silent. We met the doctor in a tiny room—too bright, too clean—crowded with white plastic chairs. I have no memory of what he said, perhaps because I was overwhelmed by what came next: my brother in the hospital bed, his face covered in white bandages, dark blood seeping through the gauze. The air smelled of antiseptic. He forced a grin, of course, always trying to make us happy. When we were in the room with him I felt everything would be fine, but when I stepped into the hall, a shadow washed over my eyes, and I woke up on the floor. I had passed out. Worried about a concussion, the doctors put me in the room next door. Our poor mother—her father gone, and now both her sons in the hospital.

I wish I could have shown her that it would be ok, that we would be ok, at least for a while. I wish I could have brought her forward six years to that night in San Francisco when my brother opened the Fillmore wearing that black patch that would become his trademark, the patch that hid more than one secret where his eye had once been.

Nico Slate is Professor and Department Head of the Department of History at Carnegie Mellon University. His most recent book is “Brothers: A Memoir of Love, Loss, and Race.”