The title tells all: That’s what Australian author Benjamin Stevenson would like you to think about his new, tongue-in-cheek mystery novel. Or does it tell you nothing? A new twist in this decade’s detective fiction is allowing the protagonist/sleuth/narrator to break the fourth wall and speak directly to the reader about the writing of the plot.
The narrator, Ernest Cunningham, is a writer of how-to guides. When called upon to solve a crime, Ernest uses the techniques he’s learned from the writings of Arthur Conan Doyle, Agatha Christie and his other iconic role models. He’s read them all. He brings the reader into the writing process, manipulating while admitting that he’s manipulating, stating Ronald Knox’s 1929 “Ten Commandments of Detective Fiction” before the story begins, and promising not to break those rules.
“EVERYONE IN MY FAMILY HAS KILLED SOMEONE”
By Benjamin Stevenson
Mariner Books ($30)
The Cunninghams are a family whose wealth has been acquired by questionable methods. Everyone has been involved in some sort of shady business, and in another person’s unnatural death. That’s true for Ernie’s brother, stepsister, wife, father, mother, sister-in-law, uncle, aunt, stepfather, his deceased father – and not to be omitted, Ernie himself. The immediate premise is that three years ago, Ernie, 38 at the time, turned in his younger brother Michael for a murder he watched him commit.
Now, Michael is returning from his prison sentence, and there’s a family reunion at a posh ski resort to welcome him home. It’s not long, however, before a new dead body is found frozen on the slopes. That’s when things start to get complicated. Ernie’s stepsister, who happens to be a discredited surgeon, finds that the corpse’s face is covered with ash – burned to death? – although there’s no melted ice in the frozen snowfield. We eventually learn that suffocation by ash was a particularly gruesome form of torture cultivated by the ancient Persians. If you think that’s far-fetched, you haven’t read the rest of this book.
When Ernie, persona non grata for his betrayal of a family member, suspects that it’s not an accident. but murder, the novel becomes an old-fashioned closed-room mystery in an out-of-the way location during a storm – or does it? The narrator/author constantly challenges the gullible reader to outsmart him by figuring out the solution. Everything in this twisted, but ultimately logical, plot is either a clue or a red herring, and nothing is what it seems to be.
By Page 104, Ernie has already felt it necessary to give the reader a recap and a backstory, including 10 “important nuggets” to remember. The last of these is, “We are 67 pages away from the next death.” It’s not a spoiler to say that the next victim will be a family member, since nearly all the characters are part of Ernie’s family (or extended family), not counting the attractive female owner of the ski lodge – and the inevitable inept local cop, who interpolates himself awkwardly into the proceedings.
On the other hand, don’t expect Ernie to get involved with the lovely landlady, because he has promised that this book will contain no sex – until it does, perhaps. Ernie teases the reader further by saying that their lips will meet for the first time in a later chapter, and that he’ll be naked when it happens. Well, let’s wait and see.
The entire book is a cat-and-mouse game with the reader. The gimmicks get more and more convoluted, until it’s just about impossible to keep up. At the “eureka moment,” when Ernie comes up with the solution (to be followed by a traditional denouement in the library), he enumerates the clues he used to put it together; 26 in all, and there are still surprises to come. You won’t outwit this author, but if you agree to play his game, it can be a lot of fun just making the effort.
Robert Croan is a former classical music writer and senior editor for the Post-Gazette. He is currently a freelance writer and lecturer in Fort Lauderdale, Florida.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.