Eight-year-old Rachel Louise Snyder came home from school one day to witness her grandmother hovering over her beautiful cancer-stricken mother, pleading in vain with her not to die. Two years later, Ms. Snyder’s widowed father abruptly moved her and her brother to a different state and wed a high school dropout he encountered at a Christian revival. “Meet your new mother,” he insisted.
In her powerfully understated memoir “Women We Buried, Women We Burned,” Ms. Snyder recalls how anger and confusion fueled her rebellion against the drastic changes her father imposed on her young life, especially the stark religiosity he came to embrace. She drank, took drugs, had sex and ran away. Her father and stepmother spanked her using the Ivy League sorority paddle that once belonged to her dead mother. She was expelled from high school (her GPA was a paltry 0.467) and finally banished from home.
Living on her own at 16, she seized opportunities and transformed herself into a globe-trotting, award-winning journalist. She married and had a precious daughter of her own. When she learned that her stepmother was dying, she went to her brother’s house to care for her.
It sounds like a predictable story of success and reconciliation, but it’s not. Her many accomplishments notwithstanding, Ms. Snyder remains angry and confused. Despite the book’s title, its central character (besides Ms. Snyder herself) is not a woman but a man — Ms. Snyder’s father — whom she describes but doesn’t understand and cannot forgive.
She remembers feeling abandoned when he left her with a Kmart saleswoman to be fitted for a bra shortly after her mother’s death. “I stood in the dressing room alone,” she laments. “I imagined my father looking at spark plugs or antifreeze.” After his spankings escalated into mutual blows, he instituted new family rules concerning curfew and chores, along with a ban on “child or parent abuse (verbal or physical).” Ms. Snyder took this to be a “shattering admission” on his part, and then promptly broke curfew while waiting for her stepsister, who had been in a car accident. Despite the mitigating circumstances, her father and stepmother threw her out the next morning. Ms. Snyder disavows a customary “my parents did their best” absolution: “You were the adults. I was the child. [Expletive] you.”
Regardless of her lingering bitterness, Ms. Snyder is a fair reporter who extols her father’s hail-fellow-well-met personality and reveals his gentle side. She tells us how he drove through the night praying for her when she escaped out her bedroom window after midnight to meet friends. At the nadir of their relationship, he wrote her: “I am blessed to have you as my daughter and proud of you.”
Still, the reason he upended her already traumatized childhood — “because God told [me] to” — remains anathema to her. Rejecting his faith, she finds meaning in deep friendships, living abroad and writing about human rights.
A measure of family healing finally takes place, not through her father, but through his wife. Ms. Snyder’s relentlessly honest memoir ends as it begins: with a woman dying of cancer. This time, Ms. Snyder is not a bewildered girl, but a tender caretaker. She warms to a woman she once despised and sees her father through this woman’s eyes.
Ms. Snyder can’t forgive, but she can accept. “I have this woman,” she asserts. “I have this mother.”
Sharon Skeel is the author of “Catherine Littlefield: A Life in Dance” (Oxford University Press, 2020).





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.