“THE CATCH”
By Alison Fairbrother
Random House ($27)
The death of a parent is a signal event in the life of an adult. For some, it is a time of grief and sadness. For others, it may bring regret, disappointment, perhaps even bitterness. When someone who has just crossed the threshold of adulthood loses a parent, it is a change of the most fundamental kind.
Twenty-four-year-old Ellie Adler is a young journalist living in Washington, D.C. in Alison Fairbrother’s debut novel, “The Catch.” Ellie’s father, James, is a minor but respected poet, parent to four children by three marriages, living happily on the Chesapeake Bay with his third wife and young son. We meet him at his best – vital and alive, charming and magnetic, presiding over a summer holiday with family all around. His unexpected death a few days later is shattering for Ellie.
As his oldest child, Ellie has always felt a special bond with him. Her parents divorced when she was small but the relationship between father and daughter was strong and loving. They enjoyed each other’s company and had easy conversations about books, authors, and the work of writing. His career as a poet and her work as a journalist only deepened their connection.
James’s lucky charm was a baseball that he kept on his writing desk. Ellie valued it as a symbol of their bond and believed that it would be hers one day. At the reading of the will, the family learns that he has left it to someone no one has ever met. So begins Ellie’s quest to discover the identity and significance of the person to whom James has bequeathed his cherished talisman. Her search puts her in touch with friends and acquaintances from her father’s past whose stories cast new light on her understanding of his life.
Ellie’s exploration brings new focus to other important relationships in her life as well. Her connection to her 10-year-old half-brother, who is deaf, deepens as she spends time with him and her stepmother in the aftermath of her father’s death. Her feelings about her own mother, now remarried and living in Florida, have always been overshadowed by the big love she had felt for her father but, as she reaches out with questions about her parents’ marriage, the relationship between mother and daughter begins to take on new meaning. There is a man in Ellie’s life, someone supportive and caring with whom she has a deep connection, but whose own life is not without complication.
Although “The Catch” is a debut novel, the writing is confident and assured with a well-structured plot and fully developed characters. Now an editor with a publishing house, Fairbrother began her career as a journalist in Washington D.C. She uses her experiences to good effect in describing the life of a young writer working in the nation’s capital. Her credentials provide exactly the right foundation to tell this story in this particular setting. Adding an interesting fact to those credentials, she is the granddaughter of E. L. Doctorow, author of such critically acclaimed and commercially successful novels as “The Book of Daniel,” “Ragtime,” and “Billy Bathgate.”
As we follow Ellie on her journey of discovery, we see how it changes the way she understands not only her father’s life but her own life as well. Those of us who have lost parents know that their voices may linger in our psyches, but they no longer have the power, or the privilege, to defend the past. We, the living, must work on our own to make sense of the life that is gone. Hidden truths may be discovered and gaps may remain but the task is now ours to reconcile the story of that life – all its successes and shortcomings, mercies and mistakes – with our own stories, the ones we live and write every day.
Lorna Kearns is an Adjunct Assistant Professor in the School of Education at Point Park University.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.