“MID-AIR: TWO NOVELLAS”
By Victoria Shorr
W.W. Norton ($26.95)
As the epigraph that adorns “Great Uncle Edward,” the first of two novellas in Victoria Shorr’s finely wrought “Mid-Air: Two Novellas,” suggests, truth is found where the past collides with the present.
Such intergenerational jarring rules both “Great Uncle Edward,” the more genteel and sallow of the fine fictions Shorr presents here, and “Cleveland Auto Wrecking,” its more-developed, slightly sunnier sequel. The first examines a moneyed family on its way down, the second an immigrant clan on entrepreneurial ascent. Both are beautifully written, their characters almost too full-bodied for the demanding, disciplined novella form. Shorr could easily have expanded these into novels, particularly the sociologically meticulous “Cleveland Auto Wrecking.”
“Great Uncle Edward” seats a family around the table of Uncle Edward, an “Aught Five” Harvard graduate who became a successful lawyer. The relatives haven’t seen each other for a while, and who knew that circumstances had changed so drastically? Shorr renders the stilted atmosphere surgically, her prose at times evoking John O’Hara in its cruel accuracy, at other times Henry James’s exquisite sensitivity to class. Yet Shorr’s vision is her own.
Uncle Edward was never quite the same after his wife died, the narrator suggests, describing the family’s one photographic memento:
“They are standing together, looking slightly away from the camera. Her hair is done up, but casually, as she must have worn it since she was a schoolgirl, and she is wearing a form-fitting knit dress, very well cut, what we should all be wearing, with her arm through his, and standing very close to him.”
Shorr’s deft interpolation, “what we should all be wearing,” colorizes a venerable, black-and-white photo, connecting it both to the narrator—the viewer in the story—and to her readers. This writer can blast the past into the present.
While Shorr keeps the focus narrow in “Great Uncle Edward,” “Cleveland Auto Wrecking” has a broader scope. It’s the story of how Sam White, an illiterate immigrant from a Balkan country so depressing it remains nameless, establishes Cleveland Auto Wrecking, his own empire of junk, in Youngstown, the northern Ohio city hardest hit by the collapse of the domestic steel industry.
Sam does more than build a business. He raises a triumvirate of sons whose conflicts and accommodations are the core of this narrative. Roy is the oldest, and the one of most flexible morality. Mel is the most conservative and stable, and B. matures late and true, even as Roy settles into a caricature of himself.
Roy and B. compete for a woman one class up from theirs. Here, Roy takes Ned, a recent divorcee, to the new country club, a cut below the older one:
“She knew everyone, but didn’t have a friend among them. They were the girls she hadn’t talked to at school, the boys who’d known not to even think of asking her out. The fact that she was there that night with Roy White instead of her own husband, a man from her own circle, had laid out her own status—‘down a peg’—for the world to see.”
As steel abandons northern Ohio, the Whites, with old man Sam again the pioneer, train their sights on the more inland, less inviting reaches of southern California, where the family evolves into a commercial development powerhouse. Roy becomes a character, running afoul of California environmental laws and Russian thugs who try to rob him. Through such images and situations, Shorr brings her depiction of the American dream—and of the American disappointment—up to date.
Carlo Wolff is a freelance writer from Cleveland.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.