In the early 20th century, Mingo County in southern West Virginia was the scene of several violent clashes between coal companies and local miners seeking better pay and living conditions. Their decade-long fight peaked on May 19, 1920, when 15 people, including seven coal company agents, were killed in a shootout on the streets of Matewan.
“DESPERATE: AN EPIC BATTLE FOR CLEAN WATER AND JUSTICE IN APPALACHIA”
By Kris Maher
Scribner ($28)
A century later, “Bloody Mingo’’ was the scene of another years-long clash between a coal company and local residents. This time, it was over clean water. Kris Maher, a Pittsburgh-based reporter for the Wall Street Journal, draws parallels between the two events in his superb new book, “Desperate: An Epic Battle for Clean Water and Justice in Appalachia.’’
The publishing success of “Hillbilly Elegy’’ has led to an avalanche of non-fiction books focusing on Appalachia. Many of them are modern David-and-Goliath tales pitting ordinary people against a justice system rigged by business interests and local politicians who do their bidding. Maher’s story is no different. In his case, it’s the residents of four small coal patches against Massey Energy, the largest coal producer in central Appalachia. With the presiding judge aiding Massey’s legal strategy, it took seven years for the residents to obtain a modicum of justice and financial compensation. The key word is modicum.
“I feel like I was cheated,’’ Kevin Thompson, the citizens’ lawyer, said of the $35 million settlement that was finalized in December 2011. He estimated that, after paying his staff and settling debts, he would earn nothing from the case.
Some of Thompson’s clients were just as disappointed. The settlement amounted to an average of about $50,000 per family after attorneys’ fees were deducted. Some received more, some less, but what really stoked anger was that some people who joined the lawsuit in its later stages received bigger payouts than those who initiated it.
“There’s a lot of us that wanted to have our day in court, but it was taken away from us,’’ said B.I. Sammons, one of the plaintiffs who objected to the settlement. “I didn’t know that could be done.… Our rights were denied.’’
The story opens in February 2004 when Thompson, a 40-year-old West Virginia native who is practicing law in New Orleans, agrees to represent a group of Mingo residents plagued with bad water for decades. The water, which ran gray and sometimes rusty from faucets, didn’t just smell like rotten eggs; it corroded water pipes and hot water tanks.
More than 700 residents of the self-anointed “Forgotten Communities” – Lick Creek, Rawl, Merrimac and Sprigg – complained of a variety of health problems. Their maladies ranged from skin boils and rashes to diarrhea, kidney stones, learning disabilities and cancer. Tests showed that their water contained high levels of lead, iron, barium and arsenic. Residents blamed their illnesses on a nearby Massey subsidiary that had injected billions of gallons of wastewater into abandoned mines, contaminating their well water.
In the book’s most poignant scene, Maher visits the home of a plaintiff he befriended. James Berlin Anderson suffered from several ailments, including learning disabilities, which Thompson believed were caused by the contaminated water. Anderson’s share of the court settlement was less than $100,000. As Maher approaches, Anderson is sitting on the front porch of his house with his wife and a family friend. His face is drained and the color of slate. He tells Maher that his renal cancer has returned. The doctor told him he will be dead in four months. He is 49 years old.
Every David story requires a Goliath. Maher’s has a doozy: Don Blankenship, “The Dark Lord of Coal Country,’’ as Rolling Stone dubbed him in a scathing profile. A math whiz at Matewan High School, Blankenship transformed Massey into the country’s sixth-largest coal producer through union-busting and relentless cost-cutting. As Massey’s CEO, he was the highest-paid executive in the state.
Blankenship embodies West Virginians’ ambivalent relationship with King Coal. He’s revered by some as brilliant, successful and loyal to his Appalachian roots. He’s reviled by others as ruthless, greedy and heartless. Years after the financial settlement, one of the plaintiffs admits that she voted for Blankenship in the 2018 Republican primary for U.S. senator.
“Out of all the people, he was as good, if not better, than anyone running and probably a lesser evil than the rest,’’ she said.
Steve Halvonik is a former Post-Gazette reporter and editor who teaches professional writing at Washington & Jefferson College.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.