The chapter titles point damningly to the reputation of Led Zeppelin: "A Law unto Themselves," "Flying Too Close to the Sun," "Their Own Private Sodom and Gomorrah." Bob Spitz's book about the seminal heavy-but-hard-to-pigeonhole British rock band looks long and deep into the group's decadent and often indefensible acts, most committed while on their legendary American tours.

“LED ZEPPELIN: THE BIOGRAPHY”

By Bob Spitz

Penguin Press ($35)

Advertise with us

But Spitz keeps "Led Zeppelin: The Biography" from being a complete tale of debauchery by also reminding readers why anyone might care about the quartet’s exploits: the music they created. Explaining how songs were written, arrangements developed onstage and in the studio, and performances built into towering displays of showmanship and power, Spitz writes intriguingly about how the band made magic through moves both purposeful and coincidental. The details of how classic tunes like "Kashmir" and "Stairway to Heaven" came together, as well as Spitz's analysis of what makes them so exciting, dynamic and singular, prove especially engaging.

Not one to simply fawn, Spitz also calls out concert appearances that lacked fire and sometimes even basic competency. A post-mortem for an especially uninspired performance nearly always comes with a note on the length of John Bonham's drum solo feature, "Moby Dick," (sometimes stretching to 25 minutes) and John Paul Jones' "rambling, pseudo-artsy introduction" for "No Quarter." Ritz also casts a critical eye at the band's recordings, praising the many highlights, but unafraid to say of a classic track like "D'Yer Mak'er" that, though "blistering,...it lacked conviction; it wasn't persuasive enough to succeed."

Spitz makes a convincing case that Led Zeppelin was ultimately guitarist Jimmy Page's band, even as he details how the group shone brightest when all four members contributed ideas and embraced an ethos of creation through improvisation. Still, it seems odd that over 100 pages in, only Page's childhood, musical development and early career are covered. Once he recruits singer Robert Plant and drummer "Bonzo" Bonham from England's Midlands, along with fellow session musician and multi-instrumentalist John Paul Jones, readers learn about the lives of the other three only in brief and it's off to the business of their becoming a world-renowned rock’ n’ roll phenomenon.

What gets lost in the ensuing tale is the humanity of the band members and other important players like their manager, Peter Grant. The tales of excess grow wearying — the degrading acts groupies would be forced to perform, the amounts of alcohol, cocaine and heroin consumed, the violence wrought on the undeserving by the band's entourage, the hotel rooms and cars destroyed, the blatant disrespect for concertgoers and fans. Spitz frequently notes that many people surrounding the band attributed Bonham's drunken exploits to missing his home and family. Fair enough. But Spitz never really shows Bonham the family man in depth; instead it's wrecked car after punched innocent after drum stool tumble after all-day bender. The drunkalogue turns horrific and stupefying long before it becomes tragic. Even then, it should feel sadder, but Bonham the percussion great and alcoholic overshadows the man.

Addiction is a terrible illness, but Page and Grant, especially, come off as terrible people regardless of their substance abuse struggles. Page takes much of the lead in the salacious, immoral sexual encounters in which others also indulged. The age-old cry of "the girls knew what they were in for and virtually attacked the band" holds no water where 13-and-14-year-olds are concerned. And Grant simply acts the narcissistic thug over and over, running the band's affairs like a mob boss straight out of a bad movie. He carries tens of thousands of dollars of band money around in cash, makes people wait hours or days after a scheduled business meeting to see him, bashes heads or has lackeys do so in the name of negotiation and retribution. It's hard to like either man by book's end and sometimes a struggle to keep wallowing through the foul muck of their lives.

Advertise with us

Spitz has assembled a thorough and detailed history of Zeppelin, and his interviews with the band's employees and contemporaries give the tale veracity. Similarly, the use of concert reviews and recordings, as well as vintage band interviews, leads to thoughtful consideration of the group's work. But the lack of new interviews with the three surviving band members is hard to overcome. It's not surprising given Zep's notoriously anti-music-press stance, but it creates another blow against them coming off as anything but arrogant, off-putting caricatures.

For the hardcore Led Zeppelin fan, there may be enough new stories about the music to warrant reading this 575-page tome. Most people would be better served to dive back into the band's eclectic, inventive, big-sounding albums to perhaps enjoy the art made by these troubled, sometimes villainous, artists.

John Young teaches seventh-grade language arts and plays in the rock band The Optimists.