It is not difficult describing what “Renegades: Born in the USA” is. The book offers transcriptions of the eight-episode 2020 podcast recorded by former United States President Barack Obama and preeminent American rock songwriter and musician Bruce Springsteen. The two men share elements of their very different upbringings in trying to capture the American story and its ideas about race, family, money, masculinity, and conflicting commitments to community and individuality.

“RENEGADES: BORN IN THE USA”

By Barack Obama and Bruce Springsteen

Crown ($50)

Advertise with us

The more difficult task is discerning why these conversations needed to be published as a book. In his introduction, Obama teases that many listeners have reached out since the podcast debuted “wanting to know a little more about the stories we told.” So both men will be following up their original Q&A responses with clarifications and additional tales? Unfortunately, no. Instead we get (admittedly, often charming) family photos, texts of presidential speeches, pictures of original handwritten song lyrics and large, bold text of the words to recorded versions of songs. The design is bright and inviting, but much of the information could be found with an internet search or is of dubious narrative value. So, if someone has heard the podcast, do they really need virtually the same information in book form?

The camaraderie these two unlikely friends share, made clear in both the audio and print versions of their talks, is certainly enjoyable to encounter. But devotees of either man, particularly if they have read any of Obama’s three books or Springsteen’s memoir, will feel plenty of deja vu. Many of the stories about their childhoods and early years in the world of politics and music have already been shared in print and in interviews — some of Springsteen’s in his one-man Broadway show, also. A person’s story is their story, but the rehashing too often gets in the way of discovering something more revelatory.

Even the title of the book and podcast feels a bit off. Renegades? Do either of the author/participants come off as unlawful, uncontrollable or wildly nonconformist? As deserters from some great ideal? Certainly both men have rebellious streaks, but as Springsteen notes in his introduction, “There is no other country that could have concocted the mix that makes a Barack Obama or a Bruce Springsteen, so our allegiance to its institutions, its dreams, and its ambitions remains unyielding.” Springsteen later dubs he and his bandmates “critical patriots,” a thoughtful designation that hardly seems to be about any great, renegade-like rejection of a set of widely-accepted values.

Despite those many complaints, the conversations recorded in this collection also have many highlights. Springsteen, notoriously private about his children’s lives, shares some interesting tidbits about how his kids have changed and inspired him. Obama sounds a bit less guarded than usual with some frank assessments of why he did and did not pursue certain policies while serving as commander-in-chief. Both men’s hard-won understanding of their fathers’ shortcomings, their deep devotion to their wives and their hope for what their children will contribute to the American story are no less than moving. And their ability to contextualize a variety of stories gives each chapter/episode shape and dynamism — These are two bright, well-read people living lives rich with very different types of experiences that they recount.

“Renegades” is no polemic, just a record of two friends talking about their roles in, and dreams for, our nation. Again, in his introduction, Springsteen notes that “within this book you won’t find the answers to ... questions” about how the American story ultimately plays out. “But you will find a couple of seekers doing their best to get us to ask better questions.” That may not have led to a book to deeply satisfy Springsteen fans or Obama supporters, but “Renegades” certainly showcases the good heartedness and verbal gifts that make both men so revered.

John Young teaches seventh-grade language arts and plays in the rock band The Optimists.