On the October day that 11 Pittsburgh Jews lost their lives inside the Tree of Life synagogue, Mark Oppenheimer sat in his car in Newton, Mass. and felt the strong tug of his own family’s history.

On the afternoon of Oct. 27, 2018, the Connecticut-based journalist and his eldest daughter were happy, having just attended a bat mitzvah and celebratory luncheon for one of her summer camp friends. Then text messages began to appear on his phone.

“There was message after message from reporter friends of mine, particularly at Tablet Magazine where I am a contributing editor, saying things like, ‘Are we going to Pittsburgh. When can we get to Pittsburgh? Is anyone on the ground in Pittsburgh?’ I had no idea what had happened.”

After reading about the lone gunman’s attack in news reports on his phone, Oppenheimer knew he must travel to Western Pennsylvania, where his family roots are five generations deep. It was the first of many trips for the former New York Times religion columnist and author whose five books focus on two subjects: religion in America and what sustains close-knit, walkable neighborhoods.

Advertise with us

On Oct. 26, Oppenheimer will sign copies of his latest book, “Squirrel Hill: The Tree of Life Synagogue Shooting and the Soul of a Neighborhood,” at Riverstone Books, 5825 Forbes Ave., Squirrel Hill. The event starts at 7:30 p.m. For more information, go to www.riverstonebookstore.com.

Earlier that day, at 6 p.m. he will talk about the book in a free virtual conversation with Eric Ackland, owner of Amazing Books and Records, through Pittsburgh Arts & Lectures. Register at pittsburghlectures.culturaldistrict.org.

“I have two great-great-great-grandfathers who were among the first Jews to settle permanently in Pittsburgh,” Oppenheimer said in a recent telephone interview.

“Isaac Oppenheimer came in the 1840s. William Frank, a third-great-grandfather, was among the Jews who bought the land for the graveyard. Oscar, my great grandfather, was the one who moved the family into Squirrel Hill around World War I. He was the third generation but the first in Squirrel Hill. His son, Jimmy, grew up in Squirrel Hill. Thomas Oppenheimer, the son of Jimmy, grew up on Aylesboro [Avenue].”

Squirrel Hill, the author said, “is the oldest stable Jewish neighborhood in American history. It has been about one-third Jewish for about a century. That is unique in American history. I was so interested in what it meant — that the worst antisemitic attack in U.S. history had come to the most timelessly Jewish neighborhood in American history.

Advertise with us

He also is interested in resilience.

“One of my beliefs is that people really thrive in close-knit, walkable neighborhoods. Since the dawn of mass shootings in America, most of the attacks have been leveled at groups of people who do not necessarily know each other or live near each other,” Oppenheimer said.

Unlike shootings at concerts, movie theaters or nightclubs, the Squirrel Hill massacre “was an attack on three congregations in a building that was central to a close-knit neighborhood. Houses of worship are communities of people who spend time together regularly by choice.”

He knew that “Squirrel Hill would have lessons for us about how to heal and move on.”

One of the book’s central figures is Tammy Hepps, a Harvard-educated woman who moved to Pittsburgh and founded Homestead Hebrews, an initiative and website that preserves Homestead’s Jewish history. In the year after the shooting, Oppenheimer said, Pittsburgh residents made a major effort to keep the community together and look out for one another. But as Jews, Hepps told the author, “That’s not the best we’re called to be.”

Advertise with us

Hepps is active with Bend the Arc, a group of progressive Jews founded in 1999. Shortly after the shooting, a visit to Pittsburgh by then-President Donald J. Trump, prompted the group’s members to protest, chanting, “Trump endangered Jews.” Bend the Arc members believe Trump supported white nationalists. The shooter at the Tree of Life synagogue expressed antisemitic views online.

Oppenheimer has many questions about the future of the Tree of Life building. The synagogue has hired New York architect Daniel Libeskind and Pittsburgh architect Dan Rothschild to reimagine the building and grounds.

“Ideally, Jewish buildings are for the living, not for the dead. The big question is: If they are going to rebuild on a grand scale, as it seems they hope to, will hundreds of Greater Pittsburgh Jews fill that building with the voices and the celebrations of the living? That is a very open question,” he said.

Tree of Life’s membership has dwindled to about 250 families.

“I understand the desire to sacralize that place and make sure it stays a place for Jewish worship. I also wonder where the worshippers are going to come from. There was no great influx of new members .What they need are people to come and keep it going every day,” Oppenheimer said.

Advertise with us

“Judaism doesn’t continue unless we prioritize the communal needs of Jewish life. We have to be making meals for new parents. We have to be coming to the shivas of grieving family members. We have to be going to brises and weddings and paying the utility bills of our buildings and the salaries of our leaders.”

At the same time, the author said, “We should be activists in domestic politics and activists in Middle Eastern politics. Judaism is about caring for each other and witnessing for the world.”

The attack’s aftermath lingers in many ways.

“One of the horrors of the attack on Tree of Life was that it taxed everyone in the community and pulled people in so many directions.... It exhausts people,” Oppenheimer said, adding, “The Jewish community can only do so much.”

Americans quickly forget gun violence, the author said.

Advertise with us

“Within two months of the shooting, if I told people back in Connecticut that I was writing about the shooting in Pittsburgh, most of them said, “‘Oh, was there a shooting in Pittsburgh?’

“I also think that for a lot of people, it was a Jewish tragedy and maybe not an American tragedy.... Jews who pass as non-Jews are completely welcome in America. The second that you do something Jewish — go to synagogue or walk around wearing a yarmulke or tell people you can’t work on Saturday, there is a little less sympathy from America at large.”

While he was writing the book, Orthodox Jews in Brooklyn, N.Y., were attacked, but there was “almost no coverage in major secular newspapers of what was happening to Orthodox Jews in Brooklyn,” Oppenheimer said.

“To a lot of people, including many secular Jews, if the attack is on observant Jews, then the victims are invisible or interchangeable.”

Marylynne Pitz is a freelance writer. Contact her at mlpitz27@gmail.com.