At work inside the Princeton University library, Belle da Costa Greene cultivated an appreciation for art, rare books and manuscripts. Her discerning eye, keen intelligence and steely work ethic propelled her to financial stability and the top of her profession in the early 1900s.
A light-skinned Black woman who passed for white in Gilded Age America, Greene’s fortunes rose in 1905 when she became the personal librarian for J. Pierpont Morgan, a powerful, wealthy financier. For decades, she worked long hours, becoming Morgan’s trusted confidante and friend. She traveled to Europe on his behalf, staying in posh hotels like Claridge’s of London and the Ritz in Paris.
Despite the job’s first-class perks, Greene was forever on guard, aware that if the truth about her racial background was revealed in a highly segregated country, she and her four siblings, who married white people, would lose everything.
Illuminating the accomplishments of heroic women like Greene drives Marie Benedict, a Sewickley-based author of historical fiction whose newest book, written with Victoria Christopher Murray, is “The Personal Librarian” (Penguin Random House, $27).
Benedict has also written fictional accounts of the lives of Mileva Maric, a Serbian physicist who was Albert Einstein’s first wife, (“The Other Einstein”) actress and scientist Hedy Lamarr, (“The Only Woman in the Room”) prolific mystery author Agatha Christie (“The Mystery of Mrs. Christie”) and Clementine Churchill, the wife of British prime minister Winston Churchill (“Lady Clementine”).
Before starting a full-time writing career in 2004, Benedict was a commercial litigator at a New York City law firm. To get a break from workplace pressure, she found refuge in the quiet, splendid surroundings of the Morgan Library & Museum.
Read More
There, a docent told her about Greene’s key role in building the stellar collection plus her insistence that it be opened to the public. That’s when Benedict put Greene on a long list of women she wanted to research.
“I did not know she was a Black woman. I just thought she was a remarkable woman,” Benedict said. “Her ability to maintain a white identity is crucial. It’s a burden that I can’t even fathom.”
Born in 1879, Greene was in her twenties when she began her 43-year career. Besides supporting herself, her income sustained her mother and four siblings in New York City. Her father, Richard T. Greener, was an outspoken civil rights leader and the first Black man to graduate from Harvard College. He served as dean of Howard University’s law school.
In the late 1890s, when he left his wife and family, they were free to change their last name and cross the color barrier. Rumors circulated about her but Greene, born Belle Marion Greener, always insisted that she was of Portuguese descent.
Greene was educated at the Northfield Seminary for Young Ladies, now Northfield Mount Hermon School, a co-educational boarding school in Massachusetts. Her mother, Genevieve Ida Fleet, had high expectations and came from an educated Black family.
“Her mother came from this affluent, educated professional community of free people of color in Washington, D.C.. Her family had been engineers and teachers and musicians,” Benedict said.
Besides living a double life, Greene navigated the male-dominated world of art dealers, auction houses and rare book libraries. In 1911, New York newspapers hailed her for succeeding at a highly competitive auction by buying Malory’s classic work, “Le Morte d’Arthur” for $42,800. The classic text, published by William Caxton, is about King Arthur and the Knights of the Round Table.
In her elegant office, Green carefully plotted her strategy for building the collection and negotiated purchases. At extravagant evening parties hosted by Morgan’s friends, she dressed in fashionable gowns with dramatic scarves, wielding an exotic femininity to her great advantage. Along the way, she had a relationship with Bernard Berenson, the Lithuanian Jewish art dealer and Renaissance art expert who passed himself off as a Boston Brahmin. First, they were intellectual soulmates, then lovers.
Before her death in 1950, Greene destroyed her personal papers. But she could not erase the birth certificate identifying her as “colored.” Nearly 50 years later, historian Jean Strouse, author of “Morgan: American Financier,” revealed the truth in her definitive 1999 biography.
Greene also could not destroy the more than 600 letters she wrote to Berenson at his home in Florence, Italy. Written between 1909 and 1949, the letters reveal much about the library world of that time. One letter, dated April 28, 1945, reads:
“Dear B.B., I cannot tell you what it meant to me — just like the dear gone days to hear from you again. I occasionally remind myself that after all we knew a grand time and lived a grand life.”
Since Greene destroyed all of her other personal correspondence, Benedict still has a key question: “We don’t know how Belle felt about passing.”
Perhaps her letters to Berenson will offer a clue. His home, known as the Villa I Tatti, is now Harvard University’s Center for Italian Renaissance Studies. The Morgan Library & Museum is underwriting a project to transcribe all of Greene’s letters, which will inform a new exhibition it plans to present in 2024.
Though Benedict left the law years ago, she said her legal training is invaluable in writing historical fiction because it taught her how to conduct research, weigh the facts and build a narrative, the same steps lawyers pursue as they prepare a case for trial. She usually works alone, but to write “The Personal Librarian,” she sought out Murray, author of “Stand Your Ground.”
“Belle deserved to have a Black woman tell her story as well,” Benedict said. “I couldn’t properly imagine or capture what it was like to be a Black woman in our country.”
The two women planned each chapter carefully, Murray said, adding that she loves to paint descriptive scenes while Benedict enjoys crafting the drama.
All of her subjects, Benedict said, are “women who are willing to fight quietly or overtly against expectations of what a woman could be, should be.“
Greene made many sacrifices. She was unable to marry because if she had a child, her race might be revealed, Benedict said.
“I don’t think she wanted to be white. It was the only way they could become equal in some respects,” Benedict said, adding that the U.S. “was becoming increasingly segregated.”
“There was no realm in which you could exist and be Black, educated and professional. Those sorts of enclaves were disappearing.”
Benedict cited the 1921 Tulsa Race Massacre, in which an angry white mob destroyed a thriving Black community in that Oklahoma town, leaving as many as 300 people dead. The authors researched lynchings and race riots to understand the era in which Greene triumphed.
“They were not widely reported, but Belle and her family would have been very aware of that,” Benedict said. “They knew what the stakes were.”
Marylynne Pitz is a freelance writer: mlpitz27@gmail.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.