The rise and fall of Pittsburgh’s industrial economy after World War II and the subsequent economic assault on low-wage workers fascinates Gabriel Winant.

At Yale University in 2018, the Philadelphia native finished his doctoral dissertation on how Pittsburgh’s economy restructured when the steel industry tanked, resulting in stark inequality. He takes up the topic again in his new book, “The Next Shift: The Fall of Industry and the Rise of Health Care in Rust Belt America” (Harvard University Press, $35).

Winant, who teaches history at the University of Chicago, speaks Friday at 7:30 p.m. in a free virtual presentation sponsored by White Whale Bookstore and the Battle of Homestead Foundation. Register at eventbrite.com.

The author’s research shows, with graphic charts, how and why Pittsburgh shifted from an industrial economy fueled by well-paid middle-class workers to a service-based economy powered by poorly paid caregivers who are often women of color.

Advertise with us

The book opens in 2013, the year UPMC, which employs 85,000 people, argued in federal court that it has no employees. UPMC’s lawyers, the author says, drew a legal distinction between the nonprofit’s parent company and its subsidiaries, contending that it was not obligated to act as an employer.

A result of this logic, Winant notes, is that Diana Borland, a medical transcriptionist UPMC once paid $19 an hour, saw her job outsourced. Her new employer paid her by the line and she wound up earning just $6.36 per hour.

In 2021, the health care sector employs more Americans than any other industry. One way to keep costs low, Winant says, is to have fewer workers.

In his book, he describes Nila Payton and her job in a UPMC pathology office where she has worked since 2006. The phone rings constantly and Payton, a medical secretary, cannot miss it. If she has to use the restroom, she has to beg a co-worker to cover for her.

On her 26th birthday, she told Winant, she held her urine for so long that “I actually peed myself,” adding that she hasn’t had more than a 15-cent raise in the past nine years.

Advertise with us

Health care jobs are “stratified by race,” Winant said during a phone interview. “African American workers tend to be stuck in the least skilled occupations in the hospital industry — environmental services, dietary and custodial.”

There are Black doctors, nursing assistants and medical assistants, but “the pattern is that Black workers are stuck in the lowest grades of the work force. That is a classic pattern in the history of labor. It tends to divide workers among each other.”

The result, he said, is that it’s “easy for the union to become the cause of the poorest and most marginalized workers in the workplace.”

That’s because employees who are earning higher salaries may not wish to jeopardize their positions for the sake of their lower-paid co-workers.

“The health care industry is a subcontractor funded heavily by the public,” because tax dollars contributed by workers support Medicare and Medicaid, Winant said.

Advertise with us

If Americans had universal health care with a single-payer system, he said, there could be real democratic debate about how many doctors and nurses are hired and what staffing levels are at hospitals and nursing homes.

“If we had that national health insurance program, it would give us tremendous power over the providers — hospitals, pharma, doctors, nursing homes. There would be one payer.

“Whose job is it to take care of our grandparents? Whose job it is to take care of the sick, the vulnerable and elderly? Do we want that to be something that we just force poor women to do?” he asked.

Americans should have a voice in that debate, he said, “rather than have profit-driven institutions decide that for us.”

“As industries develop, their products are supposed to get cheaper. Instead, profitable health care systems “pass off the cost onto the worker by holding down wages or by getting fewer people to do more work.”

Advertise with us

The problem in the current health care system is structural, he said.

“If you are going to allow private enterprise to operate these kinds of industries, you’re going to have these problems.

“We should acknowledge that like our school system, our care system carries out critical functions. It’s a public good and a public service.”

Marylynne Pitz: mpitz@post-gazette.com or on Twitter:@mpitzpg