“WHAT COMES AFTER”
JoAnne Tompkins
Riverhead Books ($28)
When there is a murder/suicide on page two, a novel can generally be counted on to deliver non-stop action and whodunit mystery through its final paragraphs. But JoAnne Tompkins’ debut novel, “What Comes After,” is not that type of book. In this introspective story, it is not the police who explore what happened and why. It is the victims and their families who struggle to discover the causes and effects of this tragedy. They are the ones who are left to analyze what caused, and to cope with what comes after the shocking loss of loved ones.
Childhood friends Daniel and Jonah, now high-school seniors in the sleepy coastal town of Port Furlough, Washington, become entangled with a homeless girl and the results are catastrophic. After their deaths, Jonah’s mom, Daniel’s dad, and the girl herself embark on harrowing interior journeys, trying to process their love, responsibility, guilt, shame, sorrow, helplessness and existential despair over the death of the boys.
Evangeline, the 16-year-old child of a broken home, has been abandoned by her mother and is left alone, pregnant and penniless. She knowingly wanders towards Daniel’s house and is taken in by his devastated father, Isaac, who is initially unaware of any connection between his son and this filthy, hungry girl. Eventually, as he learns the truth of Evangeline’s relationship with the two dead boys, they confront their inner separate, yet related turmoil, and strive to create a new human bond between them.
Read More
“What Comes After” is a novel about how people think and feel. While various locations are well-described, none of them really matter. Whether the interactions between the characters occur on a moon-lit sailboat, at an austere Quaker meeting hall, or in a noisy high school cafeteria, the setting is often irrelevant. The action takes place inside the heads and hearts of the narrative characters and the people with whom they interact.
The narration technique itself is unique. The author provides a first-person point of view from Isaac, the rigid, compartmentalized, divorced father of Daniel. Other chapters are told in third person, often through the thoughts and feeling of manipulative, cunning Evangeline, who is certain she was the catalyst for the violence. And a third point of view is also on display: several chapters are narrated by one of the dead boys, Jonah, who alone has first-hand knowledge of what actually transpired between him and Daniel.
Ms. Tompkins is clearly a student of human nature. She captures tiny gestures and nuances of behavior that are telling, yet commonly pass unnoticed. She has Evangeline describe one of her seducers: “Not only was the guy movie-star handsome, he could act, too. At least he’d mastered a way of looking at a girl as if utterly indifferent yet obsessed all the same.” Later, evicted from her low-rent home, lurking in the woods with only a candy bar in her pocket, Evangeline longs for the days “when she luxuriated in the daily petty grievances a teenage girl could harbor against her mother.”
Sometimes reading more like psychological or philosophical musings on how people perceive themselves rather than like an actual novel, Ms. Tompkins delves into the interior lives of her characters. “What Comes After” exposes the lies they tell themselves and the lies they tell the people they know, just so they can make it through a day, just so they can posit a world they can bear to live in.
The characters in this book willfully fabricate reality, wrap themselves in gauzy curtains, in an attempt to avoid the unpleasantness of their existence. The author’s implication is clear: these characters are us; we are them; we are all living in self-created fog. Evangeline doesn’t even always bother to deceive herself. “If a few so-called facts needed a tweak here or there to help those people understand – or to distract them from investigating her prior life – she’d be happy to supply them.”
Ms. Tompkins also unflinchingly tackles the topic of evil. Is it an internal or external force and are all humans susceptible? Maybe a little evil is a positive thing, because it allows us to test ourselves and prove our goodness. “What Comes After” rejects original sin: people are not born inherently evil; evil is a force that possesses us. Evangeline with her lies, Isaac with his temper, Daniel with his bullying, Jonah with his rage… everyone carries the struggle within them.
Although bleak, this novel of individual reflection and anguish ultimately resurrects the prospect of hope. Evil is not innate, and the struggle between evil and good, hate and love, resides eternally within each of us. We choose, each minute of each day, and past choices do not dictate future outcomes. What comes after is up to each one of us, and we have the capacity to choose love, mercy and understanding. Whether we do or not, well, that’s up to us.
Susan Pearlstein is an Allegheny County attorney who looks forward to once again volunteering at the Carnegie Free Library of Swissvale





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.