Today’s post-George Floyd period calls for a Thaddeus Stevens revival. The Civil War-era legislator is generally, and justly, overshadowed by Abraham Lincoln in histories of the period. But in this time of racial reckoning, of uncovering how white supremacy has been baked into so many structures of American life, Stevens’ early and forceful insistence on full equality of the races was ahead of its time. His buggy would have had a BLM sticker.
“THADDEUS STEVENS: CIVIL WAR REVOLUTIONARY”
By Bruce Levine
Simon & Schuster ($28)
Historian Bruce Levine seeks to remind readers of Stevens’ enduring importance in his new biography, “Thaddeus Stevens: Civil War Revolutionary,” a book almost entirely focused on Stevens’ political evolution and the fierce debates over slavery and the reintegration of the South into the Union after the Civil War. Could Stevens ensure that the Second Founding, the postwar remaking of the nation, would correct the injustices of the first? (Spoiler alert: no.)
Like many other Radical Republicans and abolitionists, Stevens was from New England. He grew up in Vermont, where his mother struggled to support four children after her husband left. Bullied as a child for his club foot, Stevens eventually graduated from Dartmouth College in 1814, then left New England for southern Pennsylvania to set up a law practice in Gettysburg.
A political career soon beckoned. Initially a prominent Anti-Mason, Stevens subsequently represented the Whigs, the Know-Nothings, and ultimately the Republican Party, which he joined in 1855. The through-line here was a kind of small-d democracy: He supported the establishment of public schools, opposed the secret-society elitism of groups like the Masons, and supported the right of free Black men to vote, although as a delegate to the Pennsylvania constitutional convention in 1836 he opposed eliminating the property qualification for voting.
He grew increasingly opposed to slavery by the late 1820s. This opinion wasn’t general among southern Pennsylvania voters at the time, for the region’s proximity to Maryland and Virginia fostered a great many interstate business ties, and this was a risk to Stevens’ political career (he now sat in the state legislature). But by 1838 he was an unabashed, vocal abolitionist.
Serving in Congress in 1849–53 and then again from 1859 until his death in 1868, Stevens became one of the most implacable opponents of slavery and the Confederacy. One Confederate general, Jubal Early, claimed that Stevens “inflicted more harm on the Confederacy than any other” congressman.
After the war began, racial equality became his mission. Stevens urged Lincoln to officially end slavery long before the president was comfortable doing so, and after the South was defeated, opposed Andrew Johnson’s grants of amnesty to former Confederate officials. He sought to redistribute confiscated plantation land to freed men and establish universal, race-blind suffrage across the nation, efforts undermined by Johnson and Democratic politicians in Congress. But as his health began to fail, Stevens saw the momentum behind his Radical Republican caucus dwindle as well.
Levine’s book isn’t precisely a biography of Stevens. He seems largely uninterested in Stevens as a person, and provides almost no insights into what he was like outside of his documented political opinions and causes. This is a shame, for his personal life and personality partly drove his political life.
Being ostracized for a childhood disability and going bald from a disease while still in his 20s (he wore a wig for the rest of his life), it’s hard to imagine these didn’t influence his zeal to defend the outcast, but Levine barely mentions them. Nor does he delve into Stevens’ intellectual development — the books he read, the thinkers he admired, who shaped his ideas on equality and democracy. How did Stevens fit into the school of American abolitionist thought established by William Lloyd Garrison, Frederick Douglass, and Harriet Beecher Stowe?
More curious, given his focus on the issue of racial justice, is Levine’s silence on Stevens’ relationships, especially his close and enduring tie with his widowed Black housekeeper, Lydia Hamilton Smith, which was widely publicized during his life. (In fact, the racist 1915 film Birth of a Nation depicts Stevens as “Congressman Austin Stoneman,” complete with bad wig, and lampoons his interracial entanglement with servant “Lydia Brown.” People still remembered, 50 years later.)
Although, as Levine points out, no hard evidence exists that the two were lovers, it seems strange to mention this crucial personal relationship and key facet of Stevens’ public image only in passing.
The Stevens portrayed by Tommy Lee Jones in Steven Spielberg’s 2012 film Lincoln is a hoot, with an arsenal of ornate 19th-century curses for his adversaries. But the Stevens inhabiting Levine’s book is curiously inert, even offstage for pages at a time while the author recites (admittedly relevant) legislative history. The character of the man is barely visible in these pages, and it’s a shame that he fails to draw parallels between Stevens’ radical campaign for true equality and our current moment. “Thaddeus Stevens: Civil War Revolutionary” isn’t the Stevens reboot these urgent times deserve.
Greg Barnhisel is professor of English at Duquesne University.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.