“REAGANLAND: AMERICA’S RIGHT TURN 1976-1980”
By Rick Perlstein
Simon & Schuster ($40)
Compared with the tumultuous 1960s, the ‘70s may appear uneventful. Nonetheless, Rick Perlstein reminds us, the decade laid the groundwork for the “Reagan Revolution,” a turn to the right that has had an enduring impact on American politics.
Preceded by “Before the Storm: Barry Goldwater and the Unmaking of American Consensus,” “Nixonland: The Rise of a President and the Fracturing of America,” and “The Invisible Bridge: The Fall of Nixon and the Rise of Reagan,” “Reaganland: America’s Right Turn 1976-1980” is the fourth and final installment of Mr. Perlstein’s examination of the emergence of conservatism in the United States.
Weighing in at well over 1,000 pages, “Reaganland” covers five years in exhaustive detail. An indefatigable researcher, Mr. Perlstein has unearthed material unfamiliar even to specialists in American political history. That said, had he excised marginally relevant material from his narrative (like the volcanic eruption on Mount Saint Helens and the murderous sprees of the Hillside Strangler, the Son of Sam, and John Wayne Gacy) and reduced lengthy quotations from speeches, “Reaganland” could have been much more digestible.
“Reaganland” is at its best when Mr. Perlstein focuses on the formation of the “New Right” coalition of corporate elites, trade representatives and business groups determined to dismantle the regulatory, union-friendly and progressive tax policies of the liberal state; evangelical “Moral Majority” Christians crusading against abortion, the abolition of prayer in public schools, gay rights, and feminism; and southern whites, who switched their allegiance to the Republican Party. Movements become powerful enough to change history, Mr. Perlstein writes, “when they merge diverse tributaries.”
Rick Perlstein implies that these “New Right” insurgents succeeded because they out organized their opponents, employed state-of-the-art direct mail techniques and were more ruthless. Pro Equal Rights Amendment organizations, he demonstrates, resembled top-down, hyper-bureaucratic “blunderbusses,” easily blindsided and battered by the guerilla tactics of Phyllis Schlafly’s antis, who swooped in when ratification debates were scheduled in a state legislature, and refuted abstract arguments about equal rights with horror stories about the likelihood that, if passed, the proposed Constitutional amendment would result in women drafted into combat, the withdrawal of Social Security benefits, abolition of separate bathrooms and gay marriage. Tapping “existential discontent,” Mr. Perlstein points out, has “the potential to birth revolutions.”
While the infrastructure of the Democratic Party was ineffective in recruiting, training and funding candidates, he also indicates, the Republicans provided such resources “in remarkable degree.”
That said, “Reaganland” also endorses the view that America’s right turn was the result of a perfect storm, with “the winds of history suddenly blowing in Reaganism’s way.” With President Jimmy Carter unable to resolve domestic and international crises, Mr. Perlstein suggests, Americans searched for a “nostalgic hero who could set things right” and made “Superman,” the all-powerful being “with his Norman Rockwell values intact,” the most profitable movie of 1978. Enter Ronald Reagan, who did not always have his facts straight but was unfailingly optimistic and maybe, just maybe, could keep his promise to “Make America Great Again.”
In the end, Mr. Perlstein, who does not hide his contempt for the New Right (and interrupts his narrative to refute “false claims,” “logical fallacies” and “hypocrisy”), wants to have it both ways. “The nation’s lurch rightward on economics” (and presumably other subjects), he declares, was “treated largely as if it were spontaneous.” Republican Sen. John Heinz of Pennsylvania spread the view that 93% of Americans felt that government was the major cause of inflation, apparently unaware of the fact that the statistic was based on a phony survey conducted by the American Enterprise Institute, akin to the Girl Scouts “polling its membership about whether the children should be allowed to sell cookies door to door, then selling the result to senators as the unadulterated will of the people.”
Mr. Perlstein hastens to add, however, that “these campaigns could not have taken root if the public wasn’t at least partially receptive to the message.” And that, at the end of the 1970s, “the conservative mood was popping up everywhere.”
“Reaganland” ends with Ronald Reagan’s election as president of the United States. The vast majority of voters gave “time for a change” as their reason for supporting him — an explanation that Mr. Perlstein characterizes as “not ideological at all.” Perhaps. But ideology is what they got.
Glenn C. Altschuler is the Thomas and Dorothy Litwin Professor of American Studies at Cornell University.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.