The legal and social doctrine of white supremacy was developed in the post-Reconstruction period through words — political speeches, yellow journalism, laws, pseudo-scholarly monographs. But white supremacy was implemented through spasms of violence, committed often by poor and uneducated whites but instigated and directed by the people in power.
The Tulsa massacre of 1921 has recently become the best-known of such erroneously named “race riots.” The recent HBO series “Watchmen” used it as a touchstone. But the most important is certainly the 1898 insurrection in Wilmington, N.C., because it became a template for the rest.
“WILMINGTON’S LIE: THE MURDEROUS COUP OF 1898 AND THE RISE OF WHITE SUPREMACY”
By David Zucchino
Atlantic Monthly Press ($28).
Even though Charles Chesnutt’s classic novel “The Marrow of Tradition” depicts this tragic story, most Americans don’t know about Wilmington. In his new book “Wilmington’s Lie: The Murderous Coup of 1898 and the Rise of White Supremacy,” journalist David Zucchino provides an invaluable corrective.
In Wilmington, what was described for more than a century as a “riot” was in reality a coup d’etat. Angered that the city and state not only allowed blacks to vote, but let them serve as local government officials, several former Confederate officers and Klansmen (in particular Col. Alfred Waddell) used violence to overthrow the city government and end what they called “Negro rule” in Wilmington.
While the idea that black citizens were in charge was ludicrous, Wilmington at the time was perhaps the most racially liberal city in the South. The coroner, the collector of customs, and many police officers were African American, and a black middle class of professionals, tradespeople, and civil servants thrived. White supremacists found this intolerable.
Alexander Manly, editor of the local black newspaper, angered them most. In an editorial, he mocked the South’s cherished myth that black men all want to rape white women, and suggested that some white women actually were attracted to black men.
For weeks, Waddell and others denounced Manly’s editorial, calling for his lynching. (He fled the city before they could do it.) That such ideas could be expressed at all, though, was to them evidence that Wilmington’s “Fusionist” political alliance between Republicans and Populists — and whites and blacks — had to go.
The November elections brought the openly racist Democratic Party back into power on the state and county level, but Fusionists retained local offices. The next morning, Waddell unveiled a threatening “Wilmington Declaration of Independence.”
That violence would follow was a foregone conclusion, but its scope was staggering. Almost a 1,000 so-called “Red Shirts” terrorized the city the following day, burning Manly’s offices and targeting African American neighborhoods and businesses. Troops stood by and watched as the mob murdered more than 60 people, and hundreds of black families fled the city in terror, hiding in surrounding swamps and cemeteries.
After several days, the violence abated, and the elected government — at least, those who had not been literally ridden out of town on a rail at gunpoint — surrendered to Waddell, who appointed himself mayor. Fusionists were purged from their jobs; white supremacy was made city law. Thousands of blacks voted in the 1898 election, but only five did in 1900. And history was immediately rewritten: An official inquest into the violence held the unarmed black citizens, not the armed white mobs, responsible for the riot.
Mr. Zucchino tells the story of Wilmington like a longform reporter rather than a historian, carefully cataloguing the small details and chilling individual stories of this atrocity. He makes the terror black residents of the city felt over those few days palpable. He only tips his hand at the end of the book, pointing out that today’s Republican Party and North Carolina legislature are pursuing the same goal — eliminating black political power — as the Wilmington insurrectionists, only by more genteel means.
Particularly sickening is how many supposedly respectable newspapers, and not just in the South, openly called for the rollback of civil rights before the insurrection began, approvingly reported on the violence even as it was happening, and congratulated Wilmington on restoring proper order afterward. Mr. Zucchino has done a great service in unearthing this appalling national discourse.
Wilmington remains the paradigmatic example of how white supremacists used the law, the media, social custom, as well as sanctioned (police and military) and illegitimate (mob and Klan) violence, in order to undo Reconstruction. It was a lesson to the architects of Jim Crow. Mr. Zucchino’s carefully researched book makes it clear that controlling the narrative — telling the story of Wilmington so that it served the interest of white supremacy across the nation — was likely the most powerful and enduring achievement of Waddell, and of the journalists and historians who spent the next century spreading that fiction.
Greg Barnhisel is professor of English at Duquesne University.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.