The FBI’s original “mindhunter” has just released another book about understanding serial killers.
John Douglas, a retired FBI profiler, has interviewed many of the country’s worst serial killers and developed protocols for eliciting information from them. The Netflix TV series “Mindhunter” is based on Douglas’ 1995 book about the FBI’s serial crime unit. In real life, Douglas started the FBI's Criminal Profiling Program and successfully demonstrated that knowing a killer’s personality profile can help identify him (or, in rare occasions, her).
“THE KILLER ACROSS THE TABLE: UNLOCKING THE SECRETS OF SERIAL KILLERS AND PREDATORS WITH THE FBI’S ORIGINAL MINDHUNTER”
By By John Douglas and Mark Olshaker
Dey St / William Morrow ($26.99).
This book is scattershot, bringing up interviews and profiles of several notorious murderers, but the chief subjects are Joseph McGowan, who raped and beat to death a 7-year-old neighbor girl selling Girl Scout cookies; Joseph Kondro, who raped and murdered his friends’ prepubescent daughters; Donald Harvey, a hospital orderly who killed at least 87 patients; and Todd Kohlhepp, who held women captive, raped them over days, then killed them.
None of these men is as notorious as Ted Bundy, but each sheds light on the making and mindset of a serial killer. Douglas tries to resolve whether such men are made or whether their nature is innate. Kondro’s behavior appeared biologically motivated. He was adopted, and his record showed no parental abuse.
“I felt real comfortable about killing,” Kondro said in one interview with Douglas. “I mean, killing for me, it was just like second nature … .” He had no regrets about any of his murders, only regretting he hadn’t been a better father to his children. He coolly admitted to raping girls ages 13 to 15, sometimes allowing them to live because he wanted to “keep molesting them” and because he “liked them.” This behavior was merely “a part of my lifestyle,” he said. He later chose his friends’ daughters as victims because they trusted him and wouldn’t put up a fight, which made attacking them easy.
“Do you think you are crazy?” Douglas asked at one point.
“Yeah, I think I have some issues,” came the calm rejoinder.
Unlike Kondro, however, most serial killers experienced extreme abuse as children. McGowan did not seem like such a man at first. He was a schoolteacher with a nice-guy facade. When asked how he lured his young victim into his house, he gave the cold reply, “You seem to forget that I’m a teacher, and I can command a child, particularly a child of that age, with my voice.’”
Through careful probing using a methodology developed by Douglas’ FBI unit, a colleague was able to dismiss McGowan’s lies and tease out the real reason he had killed his victim. In so doing, the colleague was able to keep McGowan from being paroled.
Donald Harvey, the hospital orderly, developed a penchant for snuffing out patients. Sometimes he used passive means — not turning on an oxygen tank, for example. Other times, he took active steps — smothering, draining spinal fluid to cause a heart attack, putting cyanide or adhesive cleaner in IVs or shoving a coat hanger up a catheter.
Harvey is the one subject that Douglas “couldn’t get to emotionally.” His statements to Douglas reveal a superficial personality with no remorse and an enjoyment of killing.
“Do you consider yourself a sociopath?” Douglas asked at one point.
“Well, that’s what most people consider me,” Harvey answered. “... I am just Donald Harvey. I haven’t changed a bit. I have been rehabilitated. I am all right. I am ready to go back to the streets.”
Douglas has the most hope and respect for Todd Kohlhepp, a mass murderer who also kidnapped women, held them hostage, raped and murdered them. Of all the killers profiled, only Kohlhepp showed introspection, a desire to understand why he committed his crimes and rudimentary remorse. Moreover, he described having a captive as “no fun at all. ...I have no idea how anyone could be turned on by that logistical nightmare, emotional mess.”
Douglas’ only stumble involved Charles Manson. He described Manson as being the son of a teenage prostitute who spent some of his formative years with his religious zealot of a grandmother and his sadistic uncle. The truth, as presented in Jeff Guinn’s 2013 book “Manson: The Life and Times of Charles Manson,” was more shaded.
Manson was the illegitimate son of an unwed 16-year-old, not a prostitute. While his mother served prison time for a botched robbery, Manson lived nearby with an aunt and uncle in a strict, working class home in West Virginia, where his guardians had little tolerance for his lies and nonconformist behavior. His grandmother, who sometimes took care of him, was a fundamentalist Christian who insisted on church attendance and reading the Bible.
This book is an easy read, full of interesting details. But Douglas often strays from his story, describing other killers before returning to his narrative. These digressions are fascinating, giving inside looks at such people as John Wayne Gacy, Gary Heidnik, David “Son of Sam” Berkowitz, Ed Kemper and Dennis “Bind Torture Kill” Rader. But they leave the reader overwhelmed with information and forgetting where the original story was headed.
John Douglas comes to no easy conclusion about what makes a serial killer. Both nature and nurture must be in play, he suggests. He seems to conclude that such people cannot be rehabilitated: “Once the damage is done, it is often all but impossible to repair it.”
Laura Malt Schneiderman: lschneiderman@post-gazette.com or 412.263.1923





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.