Reform Judaism started in Germany as German Jews sought to assimilate.

As waves of German Jews immigrated to the United States in the 1800s, they brought their ideas with them, culminating in the Pittsburgh Platform of 1885. At this meeting, 18 Reform rabbis endorsed a set of guidelines that essentially disposed of Jewish rituals and traditions in favor of ethical living and social justice.

"THE SEVENTEENTH GENERATION: THE LIFEWORK OF RABBI WALTER JACOB"

By Eric Lidji

Advertise with us

Rodef Shalom Press ($20).

So committed to these ideals was Rabbi J. Leonard Levy of Pittsburgh’s Rodef Shalom Congregation that his 1905 Passover hagaddah — the book used during the festival marking the Israelite exodus from ancient Egypt — makes no mention of God, Egypt or Israelites. Instead, without a scrap of Hebrew, it thanks America for the Jews’ escape from Europe, calls for putting an American flag on the table and for singing “My Country ‘Tis of Thee.”

It is a surprise, then, to learn that Rabbi Levy’s eventual successor, Walter Jacob, sought to return Reform Judaism to traditional laws and observances. Eric Lidji’s book “The Seventeenth Generation: The Lifework of Rabbi Walter Jacob” describes Rabbi Jacob’s life, views and career. Mr. Lidji is director of the Senator John Heinz History Center’s Rauh Jewish History Program and Archives, and Rabbi Jacob is the rabbi emeritus and senior scholar at Rodef Shalom.

Rabbi Jacob was born in Germany to a rabbi who was 15th in a family line of rabbis stretching back 400 years. The family fled to London after Kristallnacht, the 1938 Nazi-orchestrated attack on German Jews, then immigrated to America in 1940. Rabbi Jacob grew up in St. Joseph, Mo., and Springfield, Mo.

He decided to be a rabbi because of his love of scholarship and philanthropy. When Rodef Shalom’s rabbi, Solomon B. Freehof, was seeking a temporary assistant, Rabbi Jacob was the only student available at Hebrew Union College. On their first meeting, Rabbi Freehof spoke for an hour while Rabbi Jacob just listened. “I think you’ll do,” Rabbi Freehof then said.

Advertise with us

When Rabbi Freehof retired, Rabbi Jacob had to sharpen his political skills to succeed his mentor. The temple’s board of trustees wanted an older, more established rabbi. Rabbi Jacob had to win them over, going head to head with the board’s choice, an older Cincinnati rabbi.

As lead rabbi at Rodef, Rabbi Jacob implemented changes on controversial subjects with as little confrontation as possible. He began wearing a prayer shawl during services to bring that tradition back to Reform Judaism. Rather than force an updated prayer book on the congregation, he established new services for singles, families and teens, so that the congregation modernized even if its prayer book remained unchanged. He gradually brought gender equality to the congregation, officiating over the first bat-mitzvah (coming-of-age ceremony for a girl) and bringing in female speakers, assistant rabbis and cantorial soloists.

The most interesting aspect of Rabbi Jacob’s career, to this reader at least, is his work with the Reponsa Committee. Responsa are answers given by sages to questions posed by members of a community. The Central Conference of American Rabbis formed the Responsa Committee in 1905 as a compromise.

Some Reform rabbis wanted to write a book of guidelines for the faith. Other rabbis feared Reform Judaism would then become a rigid orthodoxy. The rabbis agreed instead on the question-and-answer format to give guidance without requiring adherence.

While Rabbi Freehof was committee chairman, he encouraged more rabbis to pose questions, and he published his answers, which hadn’t been done before. Rabbi Jacob, Rabbi Freehof’s successor as chairman, wanted to connect Reform Jews “more closely to the halakhah (collective body of Jewish and religious law), which has always been the central expression of Judaism.” This is an interesting opinion to hold in a denomination that was formed to separate itself from the strictures of halakhah.

Advertise with us

In his quest to bring more knowledge of Talmud (the compendium of Jewish law and commentary) to the congregation, Rabbi Jacob has had mixed results. He wrote responsa opposing Reform rabbis officiating at mixed marriages and against gay marriage. Generally speaking, Reform Jews approve of, or at least do not disapprove of, both practices. He advocated tossing out Reform Judaism’s commitment to individual autonomy and establishing codes of practice. “We must be willing to give up a certain amount of autonomy to eliminate anarchy,” he said. Reform Judaism has not rejected individual autonomy, but in practice, its religious services and observance have grown increasingly similar to Conservative Judaism, whose level of observance lies between Orthodox and Reform Judaism.

Mr. Lidji’s has exhaustively researched his subject, and his prose reads nimbly. If any criticism could be made, it would be that the focus of the book is too divided, with various aspects of the rabbi’s life and work competing for attention.

Anyone wishing to understand the evolution of Reform Judaism and learn about one of its foremost scholars would do well to read this book.

Laura Malt Schneiderman: lschneiderman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1923.