Thor, the Asgardian god of thunder and defender of Earth, is certainly an impressive hero. But would he be a good leader?

Travis Smith, author of the new book “Superhero Ethics,” certainly thinks so.

Mr. Smith rated Thor the most ethical hero of the 10 characters analyzed in the book, based on the superhero’s chivalry, noble attitude and courtesy. He ranked above Avenger teammates Iron Man and Captain America, as well as other heroes such as Green Lantern and Mister Fantastic.

Ethics and leadership are closely tied, of course, but ethics and heroism? Not so much.

Advertise with us

The moral grey area in superhero media is expansive. For example, characters like Spider-Man, who doesn't kill his opponents, still cause enormous property damage and disrupt the lives of civilians. All that mixed with a leadership role means things can get volatile pretty fast.

Which got the Post-Gazette thinking: Which superheroes would be the best leaders for Pittsburgh? And while we’re at it, which heroes would have the best leadership skills and make the best defenders against crime? Which would be the best protectors of the environment and the top developers of infrastructure?

Here’s what our readers had to say:

Leadership

As far as overall leadership skills go, readers chose Professor X, Captain America, Wonder Woman and Steel, a lesser-known hero from the Superman comic books.

Advertise with us

Professor X has certainly proven his leadership skills as the founder of the X-Men, and he made a name for himself combating the rampant discrimination and prejudice against mutants.

Captain America has proven himself worthy of a being an elected official time and time again as the courageous leader of the Avengers. Being a war hero wouldn’t go over too badly with voters here, either, especially because over 86,000 veterans called Allegheny County home in 2015.

Steel, aka Dr. John Henry Irons, first appeared in the June 1993 edition of the comic “The Adventures of Superman.” He was a weapons engineer, but he was overcome with guilt when his inventions were misused. He became a hero and tackled Metropolis’ gang violence and weapons dealing instead. Talk about a moral compass. But his skillset may be moot, now that Pittsburgh’s gun violence is at a 12-year low.

Wonder Woman, on the other hand, would actually be a bad choice as a leader, according to “Superhero Ethics.” Why? She's just “too good.”

Her ethical purity, Mr. Smith claims, would belittle her constituents instead of inspire them — in other words, they’d never be as “good” as her, and her presence would never let them forget it.

Advertise with us

Environment

Readers named Aquaman and Captain America as their top picks for environmentally conscious leadership.

Captain America is an interesting choice, considering that being eco-friendly isn’t part of his standard image. Although, it stands to reason that he might have a soft spot for the polar ice caps that kept him frozen alive for decades.

Another essential part of Captain America’s character is his hatred of bullies, no matter the size or type. Perhaps he would consider pummeling Pittsburgh’s air pollution, which is just as big a problem today as it was when Captain America was pummeling Nazis.

Aquaman is objectively a good choice — he is, after all, the protector of the oceans and its inhabitants. He’d probably get along quite well in Pittsburgh’s three rivers, and they’d be spotless in no time. We imagine the littering fines would skyrocket.

Advertise with us

Crime

In this category, readers chose Batman as their caped defender. It makes sense — his whole shtick is protecting the streets of Gotham from criminals and villains, and Pittsburgh’s urban landscape would surely remind him of his hometown.

We can see it now: the Bat-signal projected in the sky over Mt. Washington.

Batman obviously utilizes his vast wealth to fight crime, but he’s also aided by his terrifying appearance. He’s big, tall and a mixed martial artist, and that voice could scare anyone straight. Not to mention all those wonderful gadgets. No doubt there would be a partnership with Carnegie Mellon University.

But Mr. Smith claimed that Batman would actually be a terrible leader in any city. The Dark Knight’s “obsessive need for control” and “refusal to observe any limitations other than his own” are dangerous qualities, especially for those in leadership positions, according to “Superhero Ethics.”

Advertise with us

Infrastructure

Readers named Batman and Iron Man as the top choices in this category, for some pretty obvious reasons ($$$).

Batman, although obsessive and objectively scary, is filthy rich. Bruce Wayne, heir to the Wayne estate and a huge business empire, could probably finance every infrastructure project in the city and start a few more without denting his fortune. Potholes and I-279 construction, meet your match.

Tony Stark, the man in the Iron Man suit, is another billionaire, so money would be no barrier to completing infrastructure projects, and Pittsburgh’s robotics and medical programs would surely get a boost under his direction.

On the other hand, he’s a chronic narcissist who frequently and disastrously lets his ego get ahead of him, which is why, as Mr. Smith writes, Iron Man would be a mediocre leader at best.