The U.S. Justice Department has warned Apple Inc. and five major book publishers that it may sue them for colluding to drive up the prices of e-books.

Such a threat, first reported Thursday by The Wall Street Journal, could result in lower prices for e-books, but less availability.

At issue is the "agency model," a pricing mechanism Apple and the publishers agreed to in 2010, when the iPad was introduced.

Warned by the Justice Department, in addition to Apple, were publishers Simon & Schuster, Hachette Book Group, Penguin Group, Macmillan and HarperCollins. None would comment.

Advertise with us

Justice Department spokeswoman Gina Talamona confirmed that the e-books matter was open but would not comment further.

E-book sales have been mushrooming. In January 2011, Amazon said its e-book sales had surpassed printed book sales for the first time. Driven by the explosion in sales of tablets and e-book readers, e-book sales grew by 117 percent in 2011.

Under the agency model, a publisher sets a book's price, and the retailer takes a percentage, in Apple's case 30 percent.

One local bookseller said it supports the agency model because it levels the playing field. "We're for the agency model. We're not allowed to discount books, but neither is Amazon," said Kate Weiss-Duncan, a manager of the Penguin Bookshop in Sewickley, which sells e-books through its website.

In fact, fear of Amazon.com's market domination was a major reason retailers opted for going to the agency model.

Advertise with us

Publishers also back the agency model, saying lower e-book prices could force some retailers out of the market, making e-book availability shrink or concentrating sales in a few big retailers.

Printed books are sold under a different model: A publisher sells a book to the retailer at a fixed price, and the retailer can sell it for any price.

When e-books first emerged on the market, they were sold under the traditional model. Amazon bought e-books from publishers and sold popular ones for $9.99 or less, sometimes at a loss, to promote its Kindle book reader. Publishers did not like Amazon's practices because they thought its prices for e-books were artificially low.

As part of the deal with Apple for books on the iPad, publishers could not allow their e-books to be sold at less than Apple's price, effectively forcing the agency model onto the entire industry. As a result, standard prices for e-books rose from $9.99 to $12.99, then to $14.99.

As part of its possible lawsuit, the Justice Department may use material from Walter Isaacson's biography of the late Apple CEO and chairman, Steve Jobs. The book says Jobs, who died in October, was aware of publishers' frustration with Amazon.

Advertise with us

It quotes Jobs as saying: "So we told the publishers, 'We'll go to the agency model, where you set the price, and we get our 30 percent, and, yes, the customer pays a little more, but that's what you want anyway.' ... So they went to Amazon and said, 'You're going to sign an agency contract, or we're not going to give you the books.' "

At a December congressional hearing dealing with antitrust issues, Sharis Pozen, acting head of Justice's antitrust division, said her office was looking into the e-book industry.

The Washington Post quoted an unnamed federal source as saying Apple and the publishers "engaged in a pattern of behavior that violates antitrust laws."

The Wall Street Journal reported that several of the parties have held talks to settle the antitrust case and head off a potentially damaging court battle.

The Justice Department is not the only one having a problem with the agency model. In December, the European Commission said it was looking at the same five publishers for potential violations of antitrust law in how e-books were priced.

Advertise with us

A lawsuit brought on behalf of e-book customers alleges that Apple and the publishers colluded to shift e-book pricing from a wholesale method to the agency model.

Although local bookstores aren't major retailers of e-books, they do sell them and like the idea of a standard price. "Sale of e-books is a small portion of our revenue," said MaryAnne Eichorn, also a Penguin Bookshop manager.

Ms. Eichorn said the reason for selling e-books was not a monetary one but instead to stay in the market. "We have customers who use e-book readers, and we want to remain connected with them," she said.

Ms. Weiss-Duncan said it is difficult to judge the impact of e-book sales on printed books. But she said Amazon is a big competitor in both arenas, and there are issues regarding sales-tax fairness -- Amazon does not collect it -- and "other business practices that are questionable."

She noted that Amazon e-books can be viewed only on its Kindle reader. She said her bookstore tries to educate customers about "what devices give you a choice" of where you can buy e-books.