Most readers, especially in Pennsylvania, have probably heard far too much already about the deeply disturbing case of Jerry Sandusky and the scandal that so devastatingly tarnished Penn State's reputation.
"GAME OVER: JERRY SANDUSKY, PENN STATE AND THE CULTURE OF SILENCE"
By Bill Moushey and Bob Dvorchak
Morrow/HarperCollins ($26.99).
Whatever else it accomplishes, Bill Moushey and Bob Dvorchak's quick-turnaround book "Game Over: Jerry Sandusky, Penn State and the Culture of Silence" offers a case study in an important truth: Far better to read one well-researched volume, like this, than to wade through day after day of fragmentary, often overwrought and ultimately overwhelming media coverage, such as that afforded the scandal as it unfolded starting late last year.
To be clear, the bizarre saga of Mr. Sandusky and his alleged serial abuse of boys defies all understanding, whether taken in through nightly dispatches or this book-length account. What, for example, must Mr. Sandusky's wife have been thinking when she apparently heard cries for help emanating from the cellar of the couples' home, when she knew her husband was down there with a young boy? What infinitely elastic form of denial could explain either not putting two and two together or not acting on the obvious conclusion?
"The allegation that Dottie may have ignored a sexual assault in her basement provoked Dottie's only public statement," the authors write. "In a letter to the press, Dottie vehemently defended her husband and addressed the young man's allegations: '... As the mother of six children, I have been devastated by these accusations. I am also angry about these false accusations that such a terrible incident ever occurred in my home.' "
But soon a transformation came over her. "Dottie had to sign over the deed to their house and put up as collateral a $50,000 cashier's check to secure her husband's release," the authors explain. "She and her husband were also seen, surrounded by several members of their family, when they arrived at the Centre County Courthouse in early December 2011 for Mr. Sandusky's preliminary hearing. Dottie's full head of red hair had faded to gray, and the vibrant smile present when cameras caught her in good times had turned into a stoic frown. She followed her husband into court peering straight ahead. She did not utter a word, as if there were nothing more she could say."
Easily the most shocking and repugnant element of the entire scandal is the culture of denial. Repeated reports of Mr. Sandusky's bizarre carrying on with boys led to no meaningful follow-up action. This is unconscionable. It's also highly unfortunate that at the memorial for Joe Paterno, the well-deserved encomia could not have included at least a few words on behalf of the victims of abuse.
Mr. Moushey and Mr. Dvorchak are both award-winning veteran journalists and former Post-Gazette reporters. Other books will be published on the scandal that will fill in important blanks, such as providing more on the aftermath for the victims in the case and the results of the various legal proceedings, but this account provides a fair overview and a wealth of information and analysis.
It's clear the authors struggled with the question of where to come down on the legacy of Joe Paterno. An early chapter notes the "festive culture" of Happy Valley crumbling after the scandal was made public, closing with these cheery words: "But [Paterno's] legacy and demand for personal excellence, as demonstrated in so many of his players, will remain for generations."
That may be. But by book's end, the authors sound a more somber note in weighing that legacy, noting the inevitability of continued scrutiny of Joe Paterno's failure to follow up on his reports to his nominal boss of Mr. Sandusky's misdeeds.
"In the insular world of Penn State, he will always be an icon for his countless good deeds," they write. "But there will always be questions about a morality issue, one sin of omission stemming from a lapse of judgment."





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.