A simple portrait of a man gazing off into the distance, housed in the Carnegie Museum of Art, recently caught the attention of officials in the Manhattan District Attorney’s Office — and a local professor thinks the German Nazis could be a reason why.

The drawing, “Portrait of a Man,” was completed by Egon Schiele, an Austrian artist known for his contributions to the Austrian expressionist movement in the early 20th century. Drawn in pencil, it depicts the man hunched over, with his left arm stretched down and hands placed at his sides. Only the man’s head, neck, left arm, and hands are drawn.

Earlier this month, the Manhattan DA’s office announced that it had seized “Portrait of a Man,” along with two other pieces by Schiele, from the Art Institute of Chicago and Allen Memorial Art Museum at Oberlin College in Ohio.

This combo of images provided by the Manhattan District Attorney's Office, shows three artworks by Austrian expressionist Egon Schiele, from left, watercolor and pencil on paper artwork, dated 1916 and titled "Russian War Prisoner" (Art Institute of Chicago); a pencil on paper drawing, dated 1917, titled "Portrait of a Man" (Carnegie Museum of Art), and a watercolor and pencil on paper artwork, dated 1911 and titled "Girl With Black Hair" (Allen Memorial Art Museum). (Manhattan District Attorney's Office via AP)

“Portrait of a Man” is valued at $1 million. The artwork, along with two others, was previously owned by Fritz Grünbaum, a cabaret performer and songwriter who died at the Dachau concentration camp in 1941.

Advertise with us

More research would be needed to determine how “Portrait of a Man” ended up at the Carnegie Museum of Art, said Barbara McCloskey, a professor at the University of Pittsburgh’s Department of History of Art and Architecture. Museum records state that the drawing was a gift of Otto Kallir, a Austrian-American art historian, author, publisher, and gallerist.

But if history serves as a guide, there’s a chance the drawing could have once been in the hands of the Third Reich, Ms. McCloskey said. According to the Jewish Virtual Library, Nazi Germany was known to loot and steal artwork from Jews and others in the countries they occupied during World War II. Grünbaum was the son of a Jewish art dealer in what was then Moravia, and would often poke fun at the Nazis in his performances.

Much of the artwork that was stolen by the Nazis would then be sold to art collectors or museums, according to the Jewish Virtual Library. Ms. McCloskey said that Schiele’s work — often pushing the bounds of normal artistic conventions and acceptable social norms — was of particular interest to the Nazis, who preferred patriotic art, rooted in German soil and focused on its natural landscapes and beauty.

“His work would definitely have counted under the title of degenerate art … so that kind of art was especially targeted by the Nazi regime,” said Ms. McCloskey, who teaches a course called “Art in the Third Reich and Memorializations of the Holocaust” and specializes in 20th century German art.

The seizure of the portrait comes in the wake of a infamous case that concluded in 2020, where two men — an archivist for the Carnegie Library of Pittsburgh, and a local bookstore owner — pleaded guilty to stealing more than $8 million worth of rare books and parts of books from the city’s library system.

Advertise with us

Greg Priore, the archivist, and John Schulman, the owner of Caliban Book Shop in Oakland, were sentenced to home confinement, but Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Alexander P. Bicket said their sentences would have been stiffer, if not for the COVID-19 pandemic. Both potentially faced more than a year behind bars.

Ms. McCloskey said that although both stories are unique, the more recent one involving a well-known Austrian artist’s artwork is more historically significant.

“It really carries with it a much more historically heavy genealogy, than kind of a local story of people trying to make money off of collections,” she said.

The Carnegie Museum of Art issued a statement to the Post-Gazette on Friday: “Carnegie Museums of Pittsburgh is deeply committed to our mission of preserving the resources of art and science by acting in accordance with ethical, legal, and professional requirements and norms. We will of course cooperate fully with inquiries from the relevant authorities.”

It will likely be very difficult to determine the entire trail for how “Portrait of a Man” ended up in the Carnegie Museum of Art, Ms. McCloskey said. But given Schiele’s impact on the Austrian expressionist movement, the institution is, in some respect, already paying a price.

Advertise with us

“You can imagine that with the value of such an object, just having it removed from a collection is a penalty,” she said.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.