They both grew up in poverty. Both moved often as children and found school to be a struggle socially and academically. Both their fathers struggled with alcoholism. Both their brothers suffered traumatic accidents as young adults that shifted family dynamics. And yet, almost miraculously, both these women became Grammy-winning singer-songwriters and musicians.
Rickie Lee Jones and Brandi Carlile have also both written amazing memoirs of their incredible lives.
THE LAST CHANCE TEXACO: CHRONICLES OF AN AMERICAN TROUBADOUR
By Rickie Lee Jones
Grove Press ($28
“The Last Chance Texaco: Chronicles of an American Troubadour” details Jones’ journey as an adventurous, wandering child of 1960s and early 1970s America before turning to her signing with Warner Brothers Records and ascending the music charts.
“Broken Horses: A Memoir” delves into Carlile’s conflicted 1980s and 1990s American childhood, including trying to reconcile devotion to her spiritual life despite being denied baptism at her church because of being gay. Carlile then covers her unconventional path to musical acclaim and relationship-building with superstar artists as eclectic as Elton John, Joni Mitchell and Dolly Parton.
BROKEN HORSES: A MEMOIR
By Brandi Carlile
Crown ($28)
While both writers examine the psychological ramifications of their childhoods, Carlile digs especially deep into her inner life. Clearly a reader of social work researcher Brene Brown, Carlile credits much of her success navigating life and the music business to her ability to be vulnerable and authentic. To reinforce the good in her life, she recognizes the way she “gather(s) people — congregants, squads, cheerleaders,” building the communities she needs. This manifests most clearly in the semi-rural Washington state commune-of-sorts she lives in with Tim and Phil Hanseroth, the twin brothers in her band, and all their spouses and children.
Not that Carlile paints the life she has built as completely idyllic. She clearly loves her family but acknowledges times of strain with her father and brother in particular. She notes that many pharmacological aids meant to help with the rigors of touring early in her career often proved more damaging. Carlile also details discovering the psychological roots of cyclical periods of getting sick prior to especially important events.
Perhaps most importantly, Carlile recognizes that self-care takes work and self-awareness: “As I’ve learned to empathize and cope with the injustice and pain in the world, I have learned to ignore my own because it feels less and less important ... I know now that pain is relative, and never naming it contributes to the way I feel in almost any scenario where attention may be drawn to me that could result in my embarrassment or rejection.”
Lest that make Carlile’s memoir sound like a dark internal meditation, trust that light and laughter abound in at least equal measure. Carlile recognizes that her time in the pop-culture spotlight, heightened by her Grammy Awards performance of her anthemic song “The Joke” has afforded her wonderful opportunities. What a joy to read about her meeting childhood heroes, becoming friends with the Obamas, curating a day of Newport Folk Festival programming and co-founding the all-female musical supergroup the Highwomen with Amanda Shires.
Carlile even shares personal letters she penned to the likes of Adele and Eddie Vedder to ask them to contribute songs to a project she and her wife Catherine Shepherd created in support of the War Child charity. It’s a grand, warm life she’s forged and is still in the middle of living.
Not that Rickie Lee Jones, comparatively, is done living her days. Artistically, Jones remains one of music’s great wild cards, gleefully defying expectations by jumping and blending genres in her work. If there is one part of her memoir that is missing, it is an exploration of her more recent musical excursions. Nonetheless, when she tackles her initial experience writing songs, she does so with a poet’s soul: “I alone lived my life into music. My deepest emotions are universal; the further inside myself I go, the closer I am to mankind. When I sing, you can hear your own teardrops falling on my windowsill.”
Such insights spring from a life lived deeply and dangerously. Jones admits that many of the risks she took as a youth, from stealing a car and leaving home with an older boy at age 14 to hitchhiking up and down the West Coast to joining a group living in a cave near Big Sur, could have gotten her jailed, assaulted or killed. But such were the exploits she needed to pursue to decide if and how she fit into her often-fractured family. They also provided lyrical fuel once she was ready to shape life experiences into songs and work as a musical peer of iconoclastic greats like Tom Waits, Lowell George and Dr. John.
Jones’ prose is so compelling it’s tempting to share a review comprised wholly of quotations from the text. Indulge but one more, a fine example of her piercing honesty: “I did drugs like I did everything else. On fire, with no back door. I escaped, of course, and I carried my heart out in a birdcage. But she was burned, and she cried so loud, casting wild notes over water and cloud. Freed of such beauty, she waited to be freed of her sorrow ... I turned it into poetry. What else could I do?”
Jones and Carlile may be of different generations and play very different types of music, but both women share their life stories compellingly. Theirs are unique stories of overcoming challenges, finding their true selves and making music reflective of their fighting spirits.
John Young teaches seventh grade language arts and plays in the rock band The Optimists.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.