Israel, U.S. are at odds over 'red lines' for Iran

Share with others:

Print Email Read Later

JERUSALEM -- Despite attempts to align their positions on Iran's nuclear program, Israel and the United States are publicly at odds over Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's latest demand that Washington set clear "red lines" beyond which it would launch a military attack.

Mr. Netanyahu reiterated that demand Sunday at the weekly meeting of his Cabinet, urging world powers to "set moral and practical red lines for Iran" that he said could stop its "race to obtain a nuclear weapon."

The call appeared to be rebuffed by U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton, who, when asked whether Washington would lay out such "red lines" or spell out the consequences for Iran of failing to reach agreement with world powers by a certain date, replied: "We're not setting deadlines."

Ms. Clinton, who spoke in an interview Sunday with Bloomberg Radio, added that the United States has "always said every option was on the table, but we believe in the negotiation" coupled with stepped-up sanctions to influence Iran to change course. "It's a very challenging effort to get them to move in a way that complies with their international obligations," she said. "But we believe that is still, by far, the best approach to take at this time."

Mr. Netanyahu has repeated his demand for an ultimatum to Iran several times in recent days, arguing that only such a firm stance has a chance of swaying Tehran and averting a military confrontation. His position reflects a sense of urgency projected by the Israeli leadership, which views a nuclear-armed Iran as an existential threat.

Israeli Defense Minister Ehud Barak has warned that time is running out as Iran's nuclear facilities approach a "zone of immunity," protected in underground bunkers invulnerable to Israeli attack.

Mr. Netanyahu's demands, which he says are under discussion with Washington, sparked a heated exchange last month between him and Dan Shapiro, the U.S. ambassador to Israel, according to Rep. Mike Rogers, R-Mich., who was present and gave his account of the meeting.

Mr. Rogers said Mr. Netanyahu was "at wit's end" with what the Israeli leader sees as a lack of U.S. resolve to take military action if necessary to prevent Iran from obtaining a nuclear weapon. Mr. Shapiro has denied that there was such an exchange.

Explaining Mr. Netanyahu's stance, a senior Israeli official, who spoke on condition of anonymity because he was not authorized to talk publicly, said: "The prime minister strongly believes that the Iranians have to be given clarity. Only if the Iranians are presented with a crystal-clear dilemma -- that unless they stop there will be consequences, and those consequences will be grave -- do you have any hope of succeeding. If the Iranians believe they have wiggle room, there will be no change in their behavior."



Create a free PG account.
Already have an account?