The Steelers had the offseason unexpectedly thrust upon them Sunday afternoon when the Jacksonville Jaguars thumped them and then dumped out of the playoffs.
Early playoff exits often necessitate change on coaching staffs and player personnel. As defensive captain Cameron Heyward aptly put it Monday: “Some guys are going to retire. Some guys might leave. That’s just the business of the game. Everything changes. This is the last time this group will be together.”
That was the hard reality for the players as they cleaned out their lockers and left the building for an unwanted early vacation from the game. Now comes the tough part for general manager Kevin Colbert and head coach Mike Tomlin. They have some tough decisions to make regarding player personnel and where they’ll dedicate their resources both in free agency and the draft this spring.
With the news Monday that quarterback Ben Roethlisberger would like to play at least three more seasons, there is no reason to invest a draft pick in a quarterback this year. Roethlisberger is under contract through 2019 and backup Landry Jones through next season. If the Steelers like rookie Josh Dobbs as their next backup, they control his rights through 2020.
The news on Roethlisberger gives Colbert and his scouts the ability to focus on the immediate needs the Steelers must fill to remain viable contenders in the AFC.
Here are the Steelers’ top five offseason needs:
Read More
1. Inside linebacker – Before December this position would have been of much less concern, but that all changed when Pro Bowler Ryan Shazier suffered a spinal cord injury. Shazier is in a wheelchair, and the hope is he can walk again. The harsh reality is Colbert must now search for his replacement.
Last March the Steelers pursued the top free agent inside linebacker, Dont’a Hightower, who instead decided to re-sign with the Patriots. A month later, the Steelers did not draft an inside linebacker. That will change this spring. The Steelers could pursue a starter in free agency and potentially in the draft. The top free agent inside linebacker is Navorro Bowman, but he’s 29 and has an injury history that would make him a risky long-term signing. There are other options, though none with the talent of Bowman when he is healthy. In the draft, the top inside linebacker is Roquan Smith, but he’ll be long gone by the time the Steelers pick at No. 28.
It’s early in the draft process but some prospects who might be there late in the first round or in the second round are Malik Jefferson of Texas, Tremaine Edmunds of Virginia Tech and Rashaan Evans of Alabama. The Steelers could obtain two inside linebackers this offseason because their lack of depth was evident after Shazier was injured.
Sean Spence, who was signed off the street to replace Shazier, won’t likely be back, and Tyler Matakevich, the top reserve, is not viewed as a starter. Vince Williams, who took over for Lawrence Timmons as the other starting inside linebacker last season, is 28 years old. He is effective in the running game and as a pass rusher but lacks the speed necessary to play sideline to sideline or in pass coverage. It might be time to invest in a mid-round pick to groom as a potential replacement for Williams or at the very least improve the depth behind him.
2. Safety – The Steelers are in desperate need of a playmaker in the back end of their defense. Veteran free safety Mike Mitchell, who is entering the final year of his contract, certainly doesn’t create turnovers. He did not have an interception in 14 games last season and has just four interceptions in his four seasons with the Steelers. Mitchell, who will turn 31 in June, has an $8.1 million cap hit in 2018, but the Steelers could save more than $6 million by releasing him as long as they are comfortable with absorbing a $1.7 million hit in dead cap money.
Regardless of whether Mitchell is gone or remains for one more season, it’s time to find his replacement. Top safety prospects Derwin James of Florida State and Minkah Fitzpatrick of Alabama will likely go before the Steelers draft in the first round. Some prospects who could be there late in the first or in the second round and later include Ronnie Harrison of Alabama, Marcus Allen of Penn State, Quin Blanding of Virginia and DeShon Elliott of Texas.

3. Defensive line – There was a time when opposing teams didn’t even try to run the ball against the Steelers. That’s certainly not the case now. While the Steelers finished the season 10th in the NFL in rushing yards against, a more telling statistic is where they finished in yards per carry against. Opposing teams averaged 4.4 yards per carry, which was 27th in the league. That’s a big problem for the defense.
As we all witnessed in the playoff loss to the Jaguars, if a quarterback is constantly in second- and third-and-short situations, the defense is on its heels all game. The Steelers have $10 million a year invested in their starting defensive ends Cameron Heyward and Stephon Tuitt, so they won’t be looking for a starter at either of those positions. But the Steelers could draft a big disruptor to plug into the middle of their defense, perhaps a player who can play nose in the base defense and versatile enough to play outside as a reserve in nickel and dime packages. Javon Hargrave has started at nose for the past two seasons, but he’s on the small side for a nose tackle. For a team that relies so heavily on the ability to stop the run the Steelers have to find someone who can make them difficult to run against again.
4. Offensive line – The Steelers offensive line played extremely well again, but the unit could use an infusion of youth. Every starter is 28 or older. The oldest starter is left guard Ramon Foster, who turned 32 earlier this month. He’s entering the final year of his contract. The Steelers might view guard/center reserve B.J. Finney as Foster’s eventual replacement, but it wouldn’t be a bad idea to address the depth along the line either. Chris Hubbard, the versatile reserve who filled in up and down the line the past few seasons, is likely to leave in free agency. Getting younger and grooming some players for future role seems like a good idea.
5. Outside linebacker – The Steelers have a decision to make on Bud Dupree this spring. They must determine by May if they’re going to pick up the fifth-year option on his rookie contract. That decision could be foreshadowed by how they approach free agency and the draft. Dupree is entering his fourth season and has just 14½ career sacks, though this past season his first one without any injuries. It’s hard to imagine the Steelers investing another first-round pick in an outside linebacker after doing that in 2015 with Dupree and again in 2017 when they drafted T.J. Watt. The Steelers also must decide if it’s a good idea to employ their outside linebackers in coverage as much as they do. They are not rushing as often as their predecessors who thrived as sackers of the quarterback in this defense. Whatever the case, the coaches and front office must determine if Dupree is going to be part of their long-term plans.
Wild card: Running back – This position shoots to the top right behind inside linebacker if the Steelers decide not to sign Le’Veon Bell to a long-term deal or place the franchise tag on him again. Much could depend on whether they believe he’ll sit out the entire season or retire rather than play on the tag. Bell was such a big part of the offense that they would have to invest a high pick in someone to complement James Conner, or someone for Conner to complement. The good news for the Steelers if they go this route is this running backs class is deep and talented.
Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.