We regret to inform you that Eugene Melnyk, owner of the Ottawa Senators and many bad opinions, is at again.

Melnyk, the morning after Sidney Crosby accidentally chopped off a small portion of Marc Methot’s finger, went on TSN 1200 and said a bunch of goofy stuff (via Puck Daddy and the Ottawa Citizen).

He called Crosby “just a whiner beyond belief,” which, even if true, is the pot calling the kettle whiner.

He said that he “wouldn’t want to show [Methot’s injury] to anybody under the age of 25.” While it was indeed exceedingly gross, a 24-year-old probably has the constitution necessary to check it out. It’s not a snuff film.

Advertise with us

And, most relevantly, Melnyk continued his advocacy for an NHL version of Hammurabi’s Code, in which Crosby should sit for as long as Methot is out (which could be weeks).

“I think the only way to do it is you wipe the guy off the map. Not one or two games, how about a season for a few of these guys,” Melnyk said. “You take my guy, I take your guy. That’s my attitude. The guy who creates the injury, they should watch games together until the end of the season.”

This is a dumb take from a man who should not have gone on the radio while trapped in the throes of such emotion. Crosby’s play was a penalizable slash that the officials missed, something that happens, oh, dozens of times in the average NHL game.

Like Greg Wyshynski wrote at Puck Daddy, it’s not a legislatable thing; if Methot is out until the playoffs, and the Senators somehow face the Penguins, they’d be stupid not to sit him whether he was ready or not. After all, if he’s out, Crosby is out, too. That’s a door you can’t open.

Fluke injuries on standard plays are always going to happen (not coincidentally, Melnyk freaked out over a similar situation involving Matt Cooke and Erik Karlsson a few years ago). Trying to slash someone’s stick and missing is a football field way from leaving your feet to hit someone in the head. The intent is different. The body parts are different. The likelihood of injury is different.

Advertise with us

Where Melnyk may have a point, though, is that Crosby’s play was both standard and, by the letter of the law, illegal. It’s an issue the league has already dealt with this season, when the Wild systematically slashed and, eventually, injured Calgary’s Johnny Gaudreau. They broke his finger, and he missed several weeks.

“We’ve had conversations about other stars around the league and no one wants to lose a player like that. But these things happen,” Flames coach Glen Gulutzan said at the time. “Everybody has to go through this stuff. It’s just the way it is.”

This is also an area where the league has backed itself into a corner; causing injury can lengthen a suspension, but it can’t create one. If a play is deemed penalizable, but not suspendable, the book is closed.

So, there’s a lot at play. Maybe the best course of action draws from both sides: You guys can keep trying to hack, but you’re doing it at your own risk. If you hurt someone, you might sit.

For a game or two, though. That’d be fair for Crosby, all told. After that, Methot can watch games by himself.

Advertise with us

On the Clock: Are the Flyers really the Penguins' rivals?